• Existing user of old message board?

    Your username will have transferred over to this new message board, but your password will need to be reset. Visit our convert your account page, to transfer your old password over.

Loaned-Out Players

I’m pretty sure Carlo Cudicni was considered ‘small’ for a keeper but again Wikipedia tells me he’s 6ft1
 
Shortest keeper I think I’ve ever seen was John Salako when he went in goal v Wimbledon 😀
 
Unless the keeper is ridiculously short he is always going to outreach strikers to catch the ball. Having said that so few keepers these days come off their line to do it that their height is irrelevant. Body strength and weight are perhaps more important given the tendency for teams to try to block off the keeper but again a big centre back wrestling with the strikers helps that.
Whitworth is a good shot stopper and in that regard his ability to get down to shots may reflect the fact he’s not a giant. He’s not afraid to come off his line for crosses (unlike Henderson) and his distribution is decent too. Most importantly the fact he is currently the best performing keeper in the football league shows he has what it takes to succeed.
 
I know it was a long time ago, but the shortest goalkeeper I can remember playing in the top division of English football was Laurie Sivell of Ipswich Town, who is 5 feet 8 inches tall
 
Vectis said:
I know it was a long time ago, but the shortest goalkeeper I can remember playing in the top division of English football was Laurie Sivell of Ipswich Town, who is 5 feet 8 inches tall
Click to expand...
Les Green at Derby always looked shorter than that and Steve Death at Reading was too - not sure if he ever played in the top division though.
 
NMPalace said:
maybe Henry Hughton can rival that - he went in goal in the 80s (v Shrewsbury i think)
Click to expand...
yes it was - 2-2, and we were 2-0 up if I recall, Tony Finnegan got them both did he. Hughton did some good reaction saves but got caught off his line in a way which only a stand-in could for one of their goals. He want on to sheer Gerry Ryan's leg in two v the weed. God we were awful back then, I think the crowd was either 4000 or 6000. Paul Cooper and Laurie Sivvel (?) I seem to remember were vertically challenged.
 
ex hibitionist said:
yes it was - 2-2, and we were 2-0 up if I recall, Tony Finnegan got them both did he. Hughton did some good reaction saves but got caught off his line in a way which only a stand-in could for one of their goals. He want on to sheer Gerry Ryan's leg in two v the weed. God we were awful back then, I think the crowd was either 4000 or 6000. Paul Cooper and Laurie Sivvel (?) I seem to remember were vertically challenged.
Click to expand...
correction it was Steve or Terry Mahoney, Terry I think, it was 40 bleedin' years ago🤔
 
I might be 'Way off beam' but I believe it was George Wood who got injured and Henry Hughton donned the gloves. A great deal of water has passed under the bridge since those days and at my time of life the 'Memory bank' is far from in good working order.
 
NMPalace said:
maybe Henry Hughton can rival that - he went in goal in the 80s (v Shrewsbury i think)
Click to expand...

Leg breaker turned goalkeeper 😀

That’s possible, he wasn’t the tallest
 
Charles said:
Peter Bonetti was 5' 10", one of the top keepers of his day and generally reckoned to make up for his heoght with his agility.,
Click to expand...

They didn’t call him the cat for nothing

A bit like Julian Speroni, not the tallest, but certainly one of the most agile keepers we’ve ever had
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top