Israel v Hamas

[Spindle]

Palestine was never a country.

He doesn't know his facts, at all. It's like he lives in a made up world

 

[Spindle]

Isrsel is not entitled to anything, Palestine is not their country this is an illegal occupation.

'Go back to your own country' - Alan Duncan.

Where is this country you call "Palestine"? Don't see it on any maps.

 

[Spindle]

I’m assuming you’re just being disingenuous and not actually this thick.

A) you have not provided any figures or proof of population increase - you’ve just said it a few times and seem to think that makes it a fact.

B) I’ll try this complicated logic again: death count and population count are two different things - conflating them both as ‘figures’ to be accepted doesn’t make any sense. I accept the death count as provided by the IDF commander. I don’t accept a population count because it doesn’t exist.

No you just accept what suits your narrative.

The fact that you don't believe anyone on the IDF side UNTIL he said something you could get behind tells us everything.

Again, you can't prove genocide if you don't know what the outcome of the population is.

Google AI, multiple sources, say it's increased 24 to 25. I guess they know what the birth rate is and can do maths

 

[Penge Eagle]

Isrsel is not entitled to anything, Palestine is not their country this is an illegal occupation.

'Go back to your own country' - Alan Duncan.

Explain in more detail how it's an "illegal occupation".

I won't hold my breath as you've never read a history book.

 

[Penge Eagle]

Notice the way that, for some on here, being against the current Israeli government policy automatically makes you an antisemite. Not against government policy but a Jew hater.

Ah that classic bullshit argument...

Do you genuinely believe a different government would have acted differently after Israel experienced their equivalent of 9/11? How did you come to that conclusion?

 

[Wisbech Eagle]

It's a poor tactic if your aim is to wipe out a population.

Perhaps not though if your aim is propaganda!

 

[Wisbech Eagle]

Ah that classic bullshit argument...

Do you genuinely believe a different government would have acted differently after Israel experienced their equivalent of 9/11? How did you come to that conclusion?

Excuse me for butting in but that is the bullshit.

Whilst we can never be certain how anyone would react it seems highly unlikely that an Israeli government opposed to settlements in the West Bank and in favour of a two state solution would have treated the appalling actions of Hamas as an opportunity to progress an agenda they opposed.

The current government is pushing a different agenda. That’s why they are condemned. They are not just seeking the return of the hostages and to ensure the destruction of Hamas. Indeed they are threatening the future of the hostages with their current operations. Something the families have pointed out.

 

[Penge Eagle]

Excuse me for butting in but that is the bullshit.

Whilst we can never be certain how anyone would react it seems highly unlikely that an Israeli government opposed to settlements in the West Bank and in favour of a two state solution would have treated the appalling actions of Hamas as an opportunity to progress an agenda they opposed.

The current government is pushing a different agenda. That’s why they are condemned. They are not just seeking the return of the hostages and to ensure the destruction of Hamas. Indeed they are threatening the future of the hostages with their current operations. Something the families have pointed out.

Pure speculation.

 

[Spindle]

Perhaps not though if your aim is propaganda!

By Hamas on the gullible? Yup, that's working

 

[Spindle]

Excuse me for butting in but that is the bullshit.

Whilst we can never be certain how anyone would react it seems highly unlikely that an Israeli government opposed to settlements in the West Bank and in favour of a two state solution would have treated the appalling actions of Hamas as an opportunity to progress an agenda they opposed.

The current government is pushing a different agenda. That’s why they are condemned. They are not just seeking the return of the hostages and to ensure the destruction of Hamas. Indeed they are threatening the future of the hostages with their current operations. Something the families have pointed out.

What would you know? You're hardly a military strategist. Following your suggestions would just mean more dead Jews.

For the record, the USA and allies invaded 2 nations in full scale decade plus long war directly killing iro 500,000 in Iraq and Afghanistan since 2003 and 5 million if you include indirect estimates.

How does that compare?

 

[Wisbech Eagle]

Pure speculation.

Not true.

There is plenty of evidence to suggest things could change:-

https://www.972mag.com/israel-opposition-knesset-election-palestinian-parties/

 

[Wisbech Eagle]

What would you know? You're hardly a military strategist. Following your suggestions would just mean more dead Jews.

For the record, the USA and allies invaded 2 nations in full scale decade plus long war directly killing iro 500,000 in Iraq and Afghanistan since 2003 and 5 million if you include indirect estimates.

How does that compare?

As I didn’t make any suggestions that post makes no sense.