New manager poll

Who do you think will be our next manager?

  • Sean Dyche

    Votes: 32 15.5%
  • Thomas Frank

    Votes: 124 60.2%
  • Frank Lampard

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kieran Mckenna

    Votes: 7 3.4%
  • Robbie Keane

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Southgate

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • Anthony Barry

    Votes: 5 2.4%
  • Vitor Pereira

    Votes: 11 5.3%
  • Rob Edwards

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Eddie Howe

    Votes: 10 4.9%
  • Other please state

    Votes: 15 7.3%

  • Total voters
    206
  • This poll will close: .
Imagine the team was picked by a selection committee, 1940s style. No tactical instructions provided whatsoever. The players wouldn't just lose five nil every week. They'd sort themselves out to a degree and get X points.

Let's say, for arguments sake, unmanaged Team A would 'naturally' get 40 points by themselves.

I think a competent manager adds more points, but not all that many. Maybe 7 or 8? I also don't think he does it through anything clever or innovative. He does it simply by being the decision maker. 11 players might have 11 different ideas and disagree on what to do. The benefit of a manager is often that there is only one idea. Whether or not it's the best idea, or one all the players agree with, the point is to have clarity. A really good manager might have the best idea in the room, but that's only worth a little bit more than having a reasonable idea. So maybe he adds 9 or 10 points to that 'natural' 40.

A poor manager, or one insisting on the wrong idea, can subtract from that 40 quite a bit. Think of Russell Martin getting Southampton to play out from the back over and again. Did anyone think that was what the players would have done? Not only was it tactically ridiculous, they were being made to look silly by it. Thier confidence must have been in tatters by the end, going out there every week to follow an approach you don't believe in. I think a manager like that is a -15 to -20 point factor. They'd literally have been better off without a manager.

So yes, I think the manager is only ever as good as the players he's got to work with, but the players are as good as they are, irrespective of who manages them. He just needs not to mess it up. I think Sage would have been better off with the cup final players but they'd have been far worse off with him.
Not sure if I have read the last part correctly . I feel if Sage had our best 11 we would have got more points and still won a trophy . My Thinking on that as a team they had been together longer . Which would mean they understood each other's game better. We have a bunch of strangers at the moment . So getting tactics to work takes more effort. Still felt sorry for Sage . It was like being made captain of the titanic after it struck the iceberg .
 
The 'Tinker Man' won the PL at Leicester !
Carlos Corberan deploys a plethora of systems and changes formations in mid-games.
Graham Potter is not 'Wedded' to any particular system and he deployed 13 different formations across 38 games in his final full season at Brighton.
Mark Warburton was partial to changing formations during a game.
Steve Cotterill has asserted that managers have to show a willingness to be flexible with formation and tactical approach.
Sometimes that makes sense. If you have three at the back and the opponents play with one up with wide forwards then you are asking for trouble; going to a back four and ensuring the midfielders help the fullbacks when out of possession makes more sense. You would have thought the coaches would know that before the game so it would generally be when surprised with a change of shape from an opponent.

But agreed with what others have said. Football is not chess. I do not like change for change's sake because it must be harder to drill patterns of play and develop intuition between the players. Take the FA Cup run: Eze scored the same goal pretty much in the semi and in the final. There were countless other similar scenarios when the team had rhythm and could attack or defend effectively because they knew their and their colleagues' roles.
 
Not sure if I have read the last part correctly . I feel if Sage had our best 11 we would have got more points and still won a trophy . My Thinking on that as a team they had been together longer . Which would mean they understood each other's game better. We have a bunch of strangers at the moment . So getting tactics to work takes more effort. Still felt sorry for Sage . It was like being made captain of the titanic after it struck the iceberg .
Then we probably see things a little differently. I'd say if Sage had inherited the FA cup winning team, the players would have been good enough to get a few more points on the board than we currently have, but nothing like as many as that same set of players would have got under a more competent manager. Sage would still have been a negative factor, I think.

Whether the current players can get enough points under a competent manager remains to be seen, but I feel they would at least get closer to whatever their natural level is.
 
Then we probably see things a little differently. I'd say if Sage had inherited the FA cup winning team, the players would have been good enough to get a few more points on the board than we currently have, but nothing like as many as that same set of players would have got under a more competent manager. Sage would still have been a negative factor, I think.

Whether the current players can get enough points under a competent manager remains to be seen, but I feel they would at least get closer to whatever their natural level is.
Not sure I want to see our current players playing at their natural level. They need organising disciplining and motivating. Leave them alone now and there would be a rush for the door in January.
 
Not sure I want to see our current players playing at their natural level. They need organising disciplining and motivating. Leave them alone now and there would be a rush for the door in January.
I'm not suggesting they should be left without competent management, I'm just saying that if they were left without management at all they'd get more points than if left under Sage.

An organic, improvised approach by the players on the pitch is better than a harmful plan imposed from the dugout.
 
Will a new manager be announced today as many of us expected?
It doesn’t look that way at present.
No hint from anywhere of such an announcement, no sign of a press conference, no sign of any activity that journalists normally pick up on.

Does it matter that it may not happen today?

Perhaps not, but it does leave the players in limbo.
At the beginning of a training week focus turns to the next opponents in terms of preparation, video assessments, tactics etc.
Part of me thinks the longer the limbo situation continues, the less thorough the preparation will be for the Coventry game.
 
Will a new manager be announced today as many of us expected?
It doesn’t look that way at present.
No hint from anywhere of such an announcement, no sign of a press conference, no sign of any activity that journalists normally pick up on.

Does it matter that it may not happen today?

Perhaps not, but it does leave the players in limbo.
At the beginning of a training week focus turns to the next opponents in terms of preparation, video assessments, tactics etc.
Part of me thinks the longer the limbo situation continues, the less thorough the preparation will be for the Coventry game.
It's not even 9 yet.
 
The employment of Pierre Sage just illustrates how off kilter Parish & Co's thinking is. How they thought Sage could reproduce what he achieved elsewhere in the Premiership with the tools he had at his disposal is beyond incredulous. And why should he have changed his approach, that's what they employed him for!
They're either dreamers or incompetents, or a mix of the two.
Bottom line - Parish would love to have some neat and tidy fancy dan front foot football but doesn't have the revenue to fund it.
 
The employment of Pierre Sage just illustrates how off kilter Parish & Co's thinking is. How they thought Sage could reproduce what he achieved elsewhere in the Premiership with the tools he had at his disposal is beyond incredulous. And why should he have changed his approach, that's what they employed him for!
They're either dreamers or incompetents, or a mix of the two.
Bottom line - Parish would love to have some neat and tidy fancy dan front foot football but doesn't have the revenue to fund it.
Like the rest of us he's got a two gallon thirst on a two pint pocket.
 
The employment of Pierre Sage just illustrates how off kilter Parish & Co's thinking is. How they thought Sage could reproduce what he achieved elsewhere in the Premiership with the tools he had at his disposal is beyond incredulous. And why should he have changed his approach, that's what they employed him for!
They're either dreamers or incompetents, or a mix of the two.
Bottom line - Parish would love to have some neat and tidy fancy dan front foot football but doesn't have the revenue to fund it.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, it’s easy to say that now, but if Parish and co had employed a more pragmatic manager like Dyche or Roy and Big Sam in the past we would’ve all been moaning about him just wanting to make sure we stayed in the division ‘no forward thinking’ ‘missed opportunities’ etc etc
 
The lottery win is a manager who fits us, gets us, and stays with us! A latter-day Steve Coppell I suppose.

I have no idea who that is.

But just like the ticket, you have no chance until you buy it...
i think ill be happy with someone who just wants to be at Palace at this point.

Theres something quite unedifying about massively well paid players leaving for even more money straight after winning a trophy. I know its a short career but surely winning trophies counts for something, no? Dont even get me started about going on strike or deleting social media stuff.

Oh for another Coppell. That man just wanted to achieve something and would even work without a contract. Proper integrity. I dont know how much truth there is in this latest hold up being to do with Franks out of work backroom staff haggling for more, but it will reach a point when you have to wonder if they are the right choice either.
 
Last night in a local 'Public House' (Yes I do attend with some regularity !), I happened to cross paths with a supporter known to me. He was highly critical of the recruitment and in strident fashion claimed that NO manager could save the club from relegation this season.
His voice was bubbling into the high octaves as he became increasingly irate about our current plight.
 
Last night in a local 'Public House' (Yes I do attend with some regularity !), I happened to cross paths with a supporter known to me. He was highly critical of the recruitment and in strident fashion claimed that NO manager could save the club from relegation this season.
His voice was bubbling into the high octaves as he became increasingly irate about our current plight.
Tell Parish to get out of the pub and appoint a manager!
 
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, it’s easy to say that now, but if Parish and co had employed a more pragmatic manager like Dyche or Roy and Big Sam in the past we would’ve all been moaning about him just wanting to make sure we stayed in the division ‘no forward thinking’ ‘missed opportunities’ etc etc
No, it's not hindsight. After 13 seasons in the Premiership it's clear what works best for this club and the resources it can muster. Even our most successful manager played with defensive rigour as a priority.
Sage didn't stand a chance.
 
If Frank is the manager we are searching for, why does it take days & days to confirm he is in? Sage has been out for almost a week and still no new manager? What are we really waiting for - Coventry is five days away!!!!
 
Hopefully taking training today and there'll be a release of media once the session is done.

If we're still waiting then it's a bit embarrassing. The sacking of Sage was weeks in the making, how can we not be prepared for it. We need as much time as possible to prep for a massive game against Coventry on the weekend.

Hopefully all will be clear soon... Or we're currently attempting Roy's landline.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top