New manager poll

Who do you think will be our next manager?

  • Sean Dyche

    Votes: 32 15.8%
  • Thomas Frank

    Votes: 121 59.9%
  • Frank Lampard

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kieran Mckenna

    Votes: 7 3.5%
  • Robbie Keane

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Southgate

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • Anthony Barry

    Votes: 5 2.5%
  • Vitor Pereira

    Votes: 11 5.4%
  • Rob Edwards

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Eddie Howe

    Votes: 9 4.5%
  • Other please state

    Votes: 15 7.4%

  • Total voters
    202
  • This poll will close: .
Although Nuno sounded ridiculous, 20 odd staff wasn’t it? I can’t blame incoming managers wanting people they trust around them. Let’s face it in our case, was it all Sage’s fault? They’re just head coaches these days, it’s a whole team of people that can contribute to a teams success or in our case demise.
Why does he need 20 people to help him would be my first question. Maybe he wants hobbs gone 🤔. But as a owner you cant let the new guy dictate your financial policies . But I very much doubt its that many with Frank. could be salary for the help
 
The sticking points are,
- Parish wants Frank to join on an initial 2 month probationary period
- Frank has to pay for his own staff
- Paddy has to be first team coach
- Frank has no say in transfer activity in or out.
 
Well, for a start I'd be interested to know how these Twitter account owners can claim to know all this stuff. It might well be bollocks.

If it is true then I would hope all parties are being realistic. Palace have paid the going rate in the past and, up to a point, it's value for money if it works out. That's if you've got the money, of course.

Frank did a very good job at Brentford, where he had job security, respect, and not too much pressure. Managing spurs provides the opposite, and I'd think he negotiated a salary to reflect that.

Thing is, for whatever reason, he was not successful at Spurs. He is a proven mid table club manager but not a proven big club manager. He cannot ask for anything more than mid table manager wages, therefore, and will not be offered big club wages by anyone anywhere at the moment.
Past history indicates, we pay more than the average mid table team for managers. I would of thought it prudent to pay just average wages, but performance bonuses relating to success. If a manager was confident of his ability, it wouldn't be an issue.
If reports are true, Dyche tried to dictate, what he wanted in terms of players in January and was asked to close the door on his way out.
 
Here's a long-standing theory of mine...

In modern top flight football the identity of the manager doesn't matter all that much, unless he's having a negative effect.

I think the difference between a basic, competent manager and a bad one can often be significant, but the difference between a competent one and a very good one is probably minimal, at least as far as league position and points tally is concerned.

This is because the players are as good as they are at any one point in time. Even great organisation can only usually add a tiny bit to the sum of the parts, but a mad idea or poor basic organisation can completely undermine things.

I'm not saying anyone could do it, I'm just saying you could probably take one from at least half the names on the poll and we'd end up in much the same place. I don't think there's a name there who somehow magically puts us five or six league places higher than the rest could achieve, or could create a top 8 team where the others could only get us to 14th or so.

If it's not Frank, just get someone else.
 
Here's a long-standing theory of mine...

In modern top flight football the identity of the manager doesn't matter all that much, unless he's having a negative effect.

I think the difference between a basic, competent manager and a bad one can often be significant, but the difference between a competent one and a very good one is probably minimal, at least as far as league position and points tally is concerned.

This is because the players are as good as they are at any one point in time. Even great organisation can only usually add a tiny bit to the sum of the parts, but a mad idea or poor basic organisation can completely undermine things.

I'm not saying anyone could do it, I'm just saying you could probably take one from at least half the names on the poll and we'd end up in much the same place. I don't think there's a name there who somehow magically puts us five or six league places higher than the rest could achieve, or could create a top 8 team where the others could only get us to 14th or so.

If it's not Frank, just get someone else.
You may have a point.
I know we’ll never know, but if Sage had that FA cup final winning line up all in their prime at the start of this season, things would be a whole lot different. For me any manager/head coach is as good as the players he’s got to work with
Obviously some managers, sometimes through sheer force of nature and personality can make a difference, but if you’ve got players who are just not up to the job, it doesn’t matter who you’ve got in charge

So basically if I’m right, we’re going down 🤣🤣
 
Here's a long-standing theory of mine...

In modern top flight football the identity of the manager doesn't matter all that much, unless he's having a negative effect.

I think the difference between a basic, competent manager and a bad one can often be significant, but the difference between a competent one and a very good one is probably minimal, at least as far as league position and points tally is concerned.

This is because the players are as good as they are at any one point in time. Even great organisation can only usually add a tiny bit to the sum of the parts, but a mad idea or poor basic organisation can completely undermine things.

I'm not saying anyone could do it, I'm just saying you could probably take one from at least half the names on the poll and we'd end up in much the same place. I don't think there's a name there who somehow magically puts us five or six league places higher than the rest could achieve, or could create a top 8 team where the others could only get us to 14th or so.

If it's not Frank, just get someone else.
Virtually every probable candidate has had failure to temper any success, it really could be any one of them as none are bombproof including Frank. There must have been a leak or leaks to cause this much noise around Frank, but if it doesn’t happen will it really make to much difference?
 
Frank needs to take what is offered, if he doesn't go for the right man for the job, Dyche, Frank seems to overblow his importance and record, maybe a bit of an egotist, i would rather have Pardew or Popovic than, stepping stone Frank
 
Frank needs to take what is offered, if he doesn't go for the right man for the job, Dyche, Frank seems to overblow his importance and record, maybe a bit of an egotist, i would rather have Pardew or Popovic than, stepping stone Frank
You do start to think if it’s taking this long, what’s his main motive? I’ll answer my own question, money!! How bad does he want the job? Is it a case of ‘oh well, it’ll do if they pay me enough’
 
It's typical Palace.We take ages to get a transfer over the line so we are always going to take an age for a manager.It won't be done before Coventry.Board want the best but won't pay for the best.We could be doomed due to board dithering
 
It's typical Palace.We take ages to get a transfer over the line so we are always going to take an age for a manager.It won't be done before Coventry.Board want the best but won't pay for the best.We could be doomed due to board dithering
Is it dithering or not paying more than he is worth . Your assuming its the board but it more than likely Frank wanting more for his crew . He his not that special
 
You may have a point.
I know we’ll never know, but if Sage had that FA cup final winning line up all in their prime at the start of this season, things would be a whole lot different. For me any manager/head coach is as good as the players he’s got to work with
Obviously some managers, sometimes through sheer force of nature and personality can make a difference, but if you’ve got players who are just not up to the job, it doesn’t matter who you’ve got in charge

So basically if I’m right, we’re going down 🤣🤣
Imagine the team was picked by a selection committee, 1940s style. No tactical instructions provided whatsoever. The players wouldn't just lose five nil every week. They'd sort themselves out to a degree and get X points.

Let's say, for arguments sake, unmanaged Team A would 'naturally' get 40 points by themselves.

I think a competent manager adds more points, but not all that many. Maybe 7 or 8? I also don't think he does it through anything clever or innovative. He does it simply by being the decision maker. 11 players might have 11 different ideas and disagree on what to do. The benefit of a manager is often that there is only one idea. Whether or not it's the best idea, or one all the players agree with, the point is to have clarity. A really good manager might have the best idea in the room, but that's only worth a little bit more than having a reasonable idea. So maybe he adds 9 or 10 points to that 'natural' 40.

A poor manager, or one insisting on the wrong idea, can subtract from that 40 quite a bit. Think of Russell Martin getting Southampton to play out from the back over and again. Did anyone think that was what the players would have done? Not only was it tactically ridiculous, they were being made to look silly by it. Thier confidence must have been in tatters by the end, going out there every week to follow an approach you don't believe in. I think a manager like that is a -15 to -20 point factor. They'd literally have been better off without a manager.

So yes, I think the manager is only ever as good as the players he's got to work with, but the players are as good as they are, irrespective of who manages them. He just needs not to mess it up. I think Sage would have been better off with the cup final players but they'd have been far worse off with him.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top