New manager poll

Who do you think will be our next manager?

  • Sean Dyche

    Votes: 32 15.8%
  • Thomas Frank

    Votes: 121 59.9%
  • Frank Lampard

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Kieran Mckenna

    Votes: 7 3.5%
  • Robbie Keane

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Southgate

    Votes: 2 1.0%
  • Anthony Barry

    Votes: 5 2.5%
  • Vitor Pereira

    Votes: 11 5.4%
  • Rob Edwards

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Eddie Howe

    Votes: 9 4.5%
  • Other please state

    Votes: 15 7.4%

  • Total voters
    202
  • This poll will close: .
The 'Tinker Man' won the PL at Leicester !
Carlos Corberan deploys a plethora of systems and changes formations in mid-games.
Graham Potter is not 'Wedded' to any particular system and he deployed 13 different formations across 38 games in his final full season at Brighton.
Mark Warburton was partial to changing formations during a game.
Steve Cotterill has asserted that managers have to show a willingness to be flexible with formation and tactical approach.
He didnt tinker in the PL winning season, it was when he started tinkering he was Sacked.
 
That’s why none of them are plying their trade in the Premier League any longer!
Flexibility yes.
Chaos no.
I just provided a sample of managers flexible in their approach.
I do not subscribe to the thinking that 'Flexibility' and 'Chaos' are mutually exclusive.
Apropos "Chaos", Enzo Maresca likes his team to have control, he does not like chaos.
 
Understand the points raised, but on the other hand Roy, Glasner and Sage all got criticised for never having a plan B or tweaking formations to try and change a game..
Predictable and on occasions easy to nullify.
Whatever one thinks of Venables as a person, there's no doubt that he was an innovative coach who would work on alternative formations to surprise/react to the opposition.
It wasn't incessant changes for the sake of changes, but it allowed for flexibility if one needed to try an alternative approach in games.
I much prefer a coach who's prepared to adapt (as opposed to tinker).
You cannot go from 3 at the back to 4, it is to complicated, yes, subtle in game changes, in midfield, or attack, but never with the shape of the defence, in all of the games Glasner and Sage were manager, not once did we go to a front 2, not even with 15mins to go, never switched wingers, never put a CB forward for the last 5mins when chasing a game, never even hardly made a sub before 60mins, there is a difference between subtle changes, which are needed, to an all out formation change weekly or in game.
 
I just provided a sample of managers flexible in their approach.
I do not subscribe to the thinking that 'Flexibility' and 'Chaos' are mutually exclusive.
Apropos "Chaos", Enzo Maresca likes his team to have control, he does not like chaos.
Understood , but the 13 different formations used over 38 games by Potter which you mentioned is a clear case of overkill.
Can you imagine a Nicholson, Shankly, Paisley, Clough or Ferguson going in for such nonsense?
Ultimately the game is about the players ( not the managers) and the old (and valid) adage in football is that simplicity is genius.
Potter is demonstrating either a massive ego, or alternatively a deep insecurity, in this unnecessary meddling.
 
Understood , but the 13 different formations used over 38 games by Potter which you mentioned is a clear case of overkill.
Can you imagine a Nicholson, Shankly, Paisley, Clough or Ferguson going in for such nonsense?
Ultimately the game is about the players ( not the managers) and the old (and valid) adage in football is that simplicity is genius.
Potter is demonstrating either a massive ego, or alternatively a deep insecurity, in this unnecessary meddling.
In Potter's final full season at Brighton they finished 9th in the PL, having finished 16th the campaign before.
 
In Potter's final full season at Brighton they finished 9th in the PL, having finished 16th the campaign before.
Are you suggesting the improved league position (albeit to a mere mid table position) was due to using the 13 different formations in the 38 games?
Does that logic extend to it being a viable approach for other managers to employ over the course of a season?
it’s an interesting take, and perhaps I need to keep a more open mind.
 
Are you suggesting the improved league position (albeit to a mere mid table position) was due to using the 13 different formations in the 38 games?
Does that logic extend to it being a viable approach for other managers to employ over the course of a season?
it’s an interesting take, and perhaps I need to keep a more open mind.
I merely stated a fact and concluded that whilst the number of formations deployed appears a tad excessive, it did not prevent Brighton from attaining a higher position in the League.
I am not a 'Flag bearer' for constant formation changes being a panacea.
 
Understand the points raised, but on the other hand Roy, Glasner and Sage all got criticised for never having a plan B or tweaking formations to try and change a game..
Predictable and on occasions easy to nullify.
Whatever one thinks of Venables as a person, there's no doubt that he was an innovative coach who would work on alternative formations to surprise/react to the opposition.
It wasn't incessant changes for the sake of changes, but it allowed for flexibility if one needed to try an alternative approach in games.
I much prefer a coach who's prepared to adapt (as opposed to tinker).

I liked Coppells approach… get it to Wright and Bright as quickly as possible. Andy’s Grey and Thorn, stop them coming at us at any cost. It’s not hard this football lark.
 
I liked Coppells approach… get it to Wright and Bright as quickly as possible. Andy’s Grey and Thorn, stop them coming at us at any cost. It’s not hard this football lark.
That team was one of my favourite Palace teams, with each player knowing their precise role.
In this clarity of approach it reminded me of best of Glasner’s Palace.
The best teams tend to work seamlessly as a unit with little in the way of discernible weaknesses or cracks.
 
I merely stated a fact and concluded that whilst the number of formations deployed appears a tad excessive, it did not prevent Brighton from attaining a higher position in the League.
I am not a 'Flag bearer' for constant formation changes being a panacea.
Formations to me are the kings new clothes. It doesn't matter what formation you play if you don't have players with good enough footballing brains to be where they should be at any point. Sometimes you can see players sticking rigidly to their formation and attackers taking advantage. I haven't researched this season but seem to remember us conceding an unusual amount of goals from far post set pieces. That is to do with players being over coached and not using their brains.
 
In interview:

SP: "Tell me Sean, how you would set up with this group of players?"
SD: "Frankly Steve they're all s***. I mean come on, what mug recruited them? I'd recommend getting rid of them, well a least all of the most recent, and I'll give you a list I'd like to work with."
SP: "A most interesting point of view Sean, I'll keep you posted. Kindly close the door on the way out."
 
Last edited:
Maybe. But you can’t do that midway through the season. Also Dyche isn’t that good.
Never mind january, we might not be able to make substantial changes to the squad at any point. Although these things always seem unclear, does anyone have reason to believe that we have any money in the bank or are free to spend under FFP?

Many of us might argue that the team needs money spending on it, but that isn't the same as being able to do it.

It feels pretty important that the new manager is able to work with what we have in the main.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top