Israel v Hamas

[HKOwen]

You're going to need to at least prove it in some way. What have I said that was biased?

Go back a few pages and you can read about my comments on Jewish terrorism, but I don't remember you saying I was biased then.

I was chastised on the BBS for saying that Gaza will get what is coming to it directly after Oct 7th, but I was simply pointing out that the IDF were going to smash the s*** out of the place in response. I said nothing about thinking that was fantastic.

All opinions welcome on BBS, all conforming opinions that is

 

[Penge Eagle]

Which is what..? Reposting some NYtimes articles criticising Israel?

The horror!

He affirms the statement about Israel committing genocide.

His wife is pro Palestine and has complained about pro-Israel bias at the BBC (which is obvious bollox), signing a letter on behalf of Filmworkers for Palestine.

He has form in cherry-picking extreme Israeli views in a 2011 documentary The Ultra Zionists.

If you think just these points alone make him impartial then it shows your bias.

 

[CPFCSaturn]

He affirms the statement about Israel committing genocide.

His wife is pro Palestine and has complained about pro-Israel bias at the BBC (which is obvious bollox), signing a letter on behalf of Filmworkers for Palestine.

He previously cherry-picked Israeli views in a 2011 documentary The Ultra Zionists.

If you think just these points alone make him impartial then it shows your bias.

I've never said he is impartial, but I also don't think any of the above does much to counter what he showed in his documentary.

 

[Penge Eagle]

I've never said he is impartial, but I also don't think any of the above does much to counter what he showed in his documentary.

OK, we are in agreement about his impartiality.

I would say most moderate Israelis are embarrassed by many of the settlers. It's quite easy to find people with extreme views in any country and build a narrative. He's just playing to the crowd.

 

[Spindle]

'Before zionism: the untold tuth about Palestine'

Are you aware that this is an incredibly biased propaganda piece? The only correct part of this is overall sentiment that zionists are arseholes, but aside that if this is where you are getting your history lessons from then you are totally lost, and you are just going to perpetuate the problem.

I did watch it, all of it, and there are so many things that are plain wrong. Aside the constant referral to "Palestine" pre 1948 he even manages to blame the Jews for the wars against their 'peaceful' neighbours in 67 and 73, then goes on to say that the coalition invaded Iraq because the Jews told them to. There are so many lies, omissions and untruths in this that it's far to much to bother to reply to.

The entire piece is insane but you still posted it though? Honestly I would recommend that you take several steps back from it all and do some serious reading about the entire history of the region and any history that affected the region (specifically ww2) from many sources so you can perhaps garner some understanding before you blurt out, frankly, lies.

 

[HKOwen]

Are you aware that this is an incredibly biased propaganda piece? The only correct part of this is overall sentiment that zionists are arseholes, but aside that if this is where you are getting your history lessons from then you are totally lost, and you are just going to perpetuate the problem.

I did watch it, all of it, and there are so many things that are plain wrong. Aside the constant referral to "Palestine" pre 1948 he even manages to blame the Jews for the wars against their 'peaceful' neighbours in 67 and 73, then goes on to say that the coalition invaded Iraq because the Jews told them to. There are so many lies, omissions and untruths in this that it's far to much to bother to reply to.

The entire piece is insane but you still posted it though? Honestly I would recommend that you take several steps back from it all and do some serious reading about the entire history of the region and any history that affected the region (specifically ww2) from many sources so you can perhaps garner some understanding before you blurt out, frankly, lies.

The poster is a Jew hater so no surprise

 

[Forest Hillbilly]

You can be critical of Israeli government and military action, without being a Jew Hater.

"In recent weeks, thousands of Israeli reservists – from all branches of the military – have signed letters demanding that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government stop the fighting and concentrate instead on reaching a deal to bring back the remaining 59 hostages being held by Hamas." (BBC website)

There seems to be a growing realisation that committing genocide is not the way to protect civilians. Either Jewish hostages, or Palestinians. The USA and Netanyahu seem to have another agenda.

 

[ASCPFC]

I wondered if the Iranians arrested today in the UK were targeting the Israeli embassy? I suspect so.

 

[Forest Hillbilly]

By the logic Netanyahu used in Gaza, perhaps Israel should go and bomb some civilian areas in Iran in retaliation.

 

[ASCPFC]

By the logic Netanyahu used in Gaza, perhaps Israel should go and bomb some civilian areas in Iran in retaliation.

Iran attacked Israel on 1st October with missiles and drones. Previously, Israel had attacked the Iranian Embassy in Syria - and killed a couple of generals in a targeted attack. Iran/ Israel could be at the heart of all of this.

 

[PalazioVecchio]

Hip Hop group 'kneecap' are t0ssers

 

[Spindle]

You can be critical of Israeli government and military action, without being a Jew Hater.

"In recent weeks, thousands of Israeli reservists – from all branches of the military – have signed letters demanding that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's government stop the fighting and concentrate instead on reaching a deal to bring back the remaining 59 hostages being held by Hamas." (BBC website)

There seems to be a growing realisation that committing genocide is not the way to protect civilians. Either Jewish hostages, or Palestinians. The USA and Netanyahu seem to have another agenda.

But if you only criticise Israel, and the IDF, and you post pieces of blatant propaganda and outright lies, which you did and haven't taken account of that then you are a Jew hater, aren't you.

It's disgusting, you are part of the problem, not the solution.

 

[HKOwen]

But if you only criticise Israel, and the IDF, and you post pieces of blatant propaganda and outright lies, which you did and haven't taken account of that then you are a Jew hater, aren't you.

It's disgusting, you are part of the problem, not the solution.

Indeed, he and Steeleye 20 both in the Jew hating club, there's a few on here.

Anyone is entitled to be a Jew hater but don't try to hide behind semantics.

No police will knock on your door for Jew hating, whereas if you post a comment against almost anything else the police will swoop.

Simply put , the Labour Govt does not care about Jew hate ( regardless of what they say ) but is terrified of , for example, losing more muslim votes.

It's a shame the world is thus but it is.