What the hell is happening at our club ?

Fair enough, although I'm not sure about your counterexamples. I had to look it up but Plange had played 8 games for Derby before we bought him (then loaned him back). Ebiowei had played 16. It's hardly anything.

Wharton had played 44 for Blackburn. Eze over 100 for QPR. Olise 67 at Reading. Guehi 52 at Swansea. Surely scouts can be far more sure after that many games?

Not everything will work, if course. As you say, Esse had plenty of games. I'm sure it's also possible to see a player once and know he's worth a punt. Generally, though, it seems slightly self-evident that the more often you've seen a player, the less speculative the signing?

The other factor of course is cost. If you're taking a risk on a player from the Belgian league for £7m (Munoz) that's far less of a gamble than three times that much on Khalili. I would say the same about Canvot. It's notable enough to sign a player after only 19 senior games, to do it for £20m-odd takes it to a different level.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting I've pinpointed a clever equation or formula. Quite the opposite seems true. I'd reckon it's surely best to weigh all the different factors such as cost, age, sell on value, previous level of football, whether they've lived and played in England, for how long, etc and so on.

My concern is that the club seem a bit too willing to discard other important considerations to focus on age and sell on value.
Agreed. And that is my issue with the recruitment. Too focussed on potential while disregarding the present.
 
Agreed. And that is my issue with the recruitment. Too focussed on potential while disregarding the present.
Brighton have a data-driven scouting system.They assess players in Colombia,Japan, Ecuador etc etc, in the less challenging leagues in Europe and they transform modest investments into assets worth several millions eg Mitoma, Mac Allister, Cucurella, Caicedo, Baleba, Bissouma etc.
They do however sign experienced players EG Welbeck, Milner, Gross,Lallana,Veltman etc.
 
I think it was clear, splashing the cash like we did in January was a desperate attempt to get Ollie to stay, because it was so unlike us
Had to do something at the time. Had we just lost to Macclesfield, or was that about to happen? Whatever, the signings provided something of a bounce, at least JSL looks as if he wants to play for us and the rest of the season could be said to have been a success if the third tier European win against a side with a tenth of our turnover counts. And, as we keep being reminded, it was silverware with a higher currency than the Zenith Data Systems cup.

But if the £85m spend was an attempt to keep Glasner, then that was a sensational failure of psychology and even emotional intelligence.

Well: roll on the new boss. Taking a while...
 
Had to do something at the time. Had we just lost to Macclesfield, or was that about to happen? Whatever, the signings provided something of a bounce, at least JSL looks as if he wants to play for us and the rest of the season could be said to have been a success if the third tier European win against a side with a tenth of our turnover counts. And, as we keep being reminded, it was silverware with a higher currency than the Zenith Data Systems cup.

But if the £85m spend was an attempt to keep Glasner, then that was a sensational failure of psychology and even emotional intelligence.

Well: roll on the new boss. Taking a while...
Could've just given him £15 m and kept the rest.
 
Had to do something at the time. Had we just lost to Macclesfield, or was that about to happen? Whatever, the signings provided something of a bounce, at least JSL looks as if he wants to play for us and the rest of the season could be said to have been a success if the third tier European win against a side with a tenth of our turnover counts. And, as we keep being reminded, it was silverware with a higher currency than the Zenith Data Systems cup.

But if the £85m spend was an attempt to keep Glasner, then that was a sensational failure of psychology and even emotional intelligence.

Well: roll on the new boss. Taking a while...
I don’t think JSL was to keep Glasner, I think we really thought Mateta was gone and we needed a replacement.

Mateta failing that medical may have a) helped us win that trophy but also b) partly screwed us into needing to sell Lacroix.
 
Brighton have a data-driven scouting system.They assess players in Colombia,Japan, Ecuador etc etc, in the less challenging leagues in Europe and they transform modest investments into assets worth several millions eg Mitoma, Mac Allister, Cucurella, Caicedo, Baleba, Bissouma etc.
They do however sign experienced players EG Welbeck, Milner, Gross,Lallana,Veltman etc.
That is the most relative part which we are lacking
 
Had to do something at the time. Had we just lost to Macclesfield, or was that about to happen? Whatever, the signings provided something of a bounce, at least JSL looks as if he wants to play for us and the rest of the season could be said to have been a success if the third tier European win against a side with a tenth of our turnover counts. And, as we keep being reminded, it was silverware with a higher currency than the Zenith Data Systems cup.

But if the £85m spend was an attempt to keep Glasner, then that was a sensational failure of psychology and even emotional intelligence.

Well: roll on the new boss. Taking a while...
Yes although it felt like we wasted a lot of money and not a great deal of thought went into it, desperate in other words, as you say at least he wants to be here and whatever people feel about his ability and price tag, he has contributed with 8 goals in which apart from winning the conference has been a tough calendar year
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top