What the hell is happening at our club ?

It could just be that Frank will fail the Palace four day medical. Or that West Ham will sign him anyway.

It is all too likely that the new manager, if there is to be one (why not trailblaze with an acephalous set up- better still, let the players decide - who plays, what the tactics are, whether training happens before 4p.m.etc.?) will have about six hours with the team before the Coventry match.

Why this farce? If it had been decided to sack Pierre Sage in the event of a defeat by Liverpool (hardly unexpected), why not do so straight after the game? Or are we so honourable that we would not dream of sounding out Frank or Dyche before giving Sage the push? Highly unlikely.
Fail a Palace medical? Good grief, that poor man.
 
Yeah
I regularly play Football Manager and I can change my Manager in less than 5 minutes. Come on Parish, what the F are you doing ?
I have watched this club since 1949 patiently witnessing any number of disappointments. I wouldn’t dream of wasting my time with any form of fantasy football, other than the fantasy we all indulge in when it comes to Palace.
I merely asked a question with the observation that many have made before me that Palaces business is often conducted at a snails pace. Sorry if that causes any frustration on your part.
 
Journos create and cause mischief and need willing victims to soak it all up. Lots of folk getting in on the drama who like to stir the pot. Does it help? No not really.

So please don't ruin it with daft posts like yours! It is simply business as usual, it seems some fans want to cause chaos and then blame the club for the noise!

I'll tell you whats happening at a club, its called Peak Palace, its never been this good before:
A well run club on a solid financial standing​
2 major trophy wins (I dont count Community Shield)​
13 successive years in the PM​
A new main stand on the horizon too (maybe)😉​
Completely agree my friend, good to hear someone isn't so downbeat.
All clubs go through phases and we are currently in ours...again.
I do suspect things are going on behind the scenes with the owners but that's common practice and Parish as much as can be frustrating is quite a good businessman, just check his history.
 
Having gone through two administrations, countless relegations, manager changes etc I don’t think there is anything out of the ordinary to worry about. We are on the Palace rollercoaster in the EPL Theme Park. It’s risky, sometimes terrifying but there is a sense of elation and achievement at the end of each season. It’s better than the swings at a children’s playground as long as we avoid the Big Dipper!
 
Outside of the manager situation we have had a number of seasons not to different to where we are now. How could it ever have been different? There are at least twenty other clubs in our category of potential , and we have topped the class , but it could never be without knowing we had hit the ceiling , we have mega rich owners but the rules say , no further.
We have rarely if ever been able to dismiss relegation completely, and that’s where we are now. This is Parish’s experience, he has dealt with this all the way along and my money says he will again. If he doesn’t and it is only an if, it’s not the end of the world the Championship is where we searched for glory for much of our history we can come again.
 
Outside of the manager situation we have had a number of seasons not to different to where we are now. How could it ever have been different? There are at least twenty other clubs in our category of potential , and we have topped the class , but it could never be without knowing we had hit the ceiling , we have mega rich owners but the rules say , no further.
We have rarely if ever been able to dismiss relegation completely, and that’s where we are now. This is Parish’s experience, he has dealt with this all the way along and my money says he will again. If he doesn’t and it is only an if, it’s not the end of the world the Championship is where we searched for glory for much of our history we can come again.
We are definitely in a much healthier financial position than when we came up in 2013 arent we.
 
But we won two trophies with him, and put ourselves on course to win a third with his teenage replacement playing (at the time) very well. If we well Guehi in the summer of 24/25, do you think we achieve any of that?

This is where the 'maximise value' argument struggles a bit, because sometimes you have to accept that you need to bend those rules a bit.
No. That’s in fact the point I was making. It’s a trade off. In Guehi’s case we made the decision we were better off with him than cashing in on him. What I was saying is it is a difficult call to get right
 
I get the feeling this has happened to previous "established" premier league clubs who now reside in lower divisions.
They didn't have Steve Parish in charge of those clubs.
Do NOT get me wrong. I dont see him as beyond criticism. He has made mistakes in the past and some of the mess we're in right now is down to him but... In the past when backs are against the wall he has always acted decisively. The main one was bringing in Allardyce and handing him money we didn't have for Luca, PVA and Sakho.
He'll do whats necessary again. If Frank has accepted the job on condition we bring in a couple of players he wants? Trust me, Parish will bring them in
 
It’s probably been said before but Parish really should have kept Lacroix until we had a top class replacement lined up. If it’s a case we had no money due to wasting 85m in January then our recruitment guy should have been sacked with Sage. We should go back to the days when the manager signed the players and we didn’t even know or cared who the chairman was.
 
It’s probably been said before but Parish really should have kept Lacroix until we had a top class replacement lined up. If it’s a case we had no money due to wasting 85m in January then our recruitment guy should have been sacked with Sage. We should go back to the days when the manager signed the players and we didn’t even know or cared who the chairman was.
The story goes that Lacroix rang Parish from the World Cup camp and said he was off to Chelsea. A Chelsea player for France will have tapped him up.
 
The story goes that Lacroix rang Parish from the World Cup camp and said he was off to Chelsea. A Chelsea player for France will have tapped him up.
If we hadn’t sold him we could well have ended up with another Sarr situation. Admittedly Lacroix doesn’t come across as that sort of character but then players often don’t until they do. The issue was less selling Lacroix and more not signing a decent centre half
 
If we hadn’t sold him we could well have ended up with another Sarr situation. Admittedly Lacroix doesn’t come across as that sort of character but then players often don’t until they do. The issue was less selling Lacroix and more not signing a decent centre half
I will say, I don't actually think ours are that bad. Maybe pretty average, yes, but not as poor as our goals against are. I get the feeling the Chelsea guy could end up really good and could possibly show something this season. Richards is hardly poor, not great perhaps. Disasi is ok, a bit reckless. We've been happy enough with Canvot before - we know he can be ok. Tomiyasu has pedigree. Lerma seems to be fine. Individually, they're not poor players. I'd rate them better than Andersen, for example. I know he's not a regular starter but he's still Premier League standard. Full backs - we're fine. Depends how we use them. Not bombing up and down the wings would help. Or not really bombing anymore after about fifteen minutes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JHB
It’s probably been said before but Parish really should have kept Lacroix until we had a top class replacement lined up. If it’s a case we had no money due to wasting 85m in January then our recruitment guy should have been sacked with Sage. We should go back to the days when the manager signed the players and we didn’t even know or cared who the chairman was.
It was either Lacroix or Wharton, that had to be sold to comply with PSR rules. The January signings didn't work out as expected and Johnson turned out to be a disaster, apparently it was Glasner, who wanted him, so to placate him the club went along with it. The end result Glasner was motivated enough to lead us to the Conference League cup.
 
You've just picked the examples that suit your argument there though? Esse had two decent seasons in the Champ, Plange had a year and Ebiowei had half a year and where did they go?

While Munoz was also playing in Belgium same as Khalaili and he was a roaring success? And in Canvot's case I'd argue that playing six games against the top five in Ligue 1 (including twice against PSG) does count for something. Doucoure was another who was a 22-year old with a couple of seasons in Ligue 1 under his belt and he was a brilliant signing.

I just don't think there is a hard and fast rule that means the Championships is obviously a better predictor of talent.
Fair enough, although I'm not sure about your counterexamples. I had to look it up but Plange had played 8 games for Derby before we bought him (then loaned him back). Ebiowei had played 16. It's hardly anything.

Wharton had played 44 for Blackburn. Eze over 100 for QPR. Olise 67 at Reading. Guehi 52 at Swansea. Surely scouts can be far more sure after that many games?

Not everything will work, if course. As you say, Esse had plenty of games. I'm sure it's also possible to see a player once and know he's worth a punt. Generally, though, it seems slightly self-evident that the more often you've seen a player, the less speculative the signing?

The other factor of course is cost. If you're taking a risk on a player from the Belgian league for £7m (Munoz) that's far less of a gamble than three times that much on Khalili. I would say the same about Canvot. It's notable enough to sign a player after only 19 senior games, to do it for £20m-odd takes it to a different level.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting I've pinpointed a clever equation or formula. Quite the opposite seems true. I'd reckon it's surely best to weigh all the different factors such as cost, age, sell on value, previous level of football, whether they've lived and played in England, for how long, etc and so on.

My concern is that the club seem a bit too willing to discard other important considerations to focus on age and sell on value.
 
Last edited:
It is possible Osorio, Canvot, Khalaili, and Gozo will come good once they’re given a chance in an organised team. If so we may eventually sing Hobbs’ praises, but for the moment there are 3 significant strikes against his name. Firstly signing JSL on the assumption JP was going, secondly selling Lacroix on the assumption Ordonez was coming, and thirdly signing Johnson full stop. Three strikes and you’re out in my book.
I understand why we brought johnson. sadly didn't know he had lost it all . Just thought Frank had his own agenda about him . And maybe still has but not sure
 
Fair enough, although I'm not sure about your counterexamples. I had to look it up but Plange had played 8 games for Derby before we bought him (then loaned him back). Ebiowei had played 16. It's hardly anything.

Wharton had played 44 for Blackburn. Eze over 100 for QPR. Olise 67 at Reading. Guehi 52 at Swansea. Surely scouts can be far more sure after that many games?

Not everything will work, if course. As you say, Esse had plenty of games. I'm sure it's also possible to see a player once and know he's worth a punt. Generally, though, it seems slightly self-evident that the more often you've seen a player, the less speculative the signing?

The other factor of course is cost. If you're taking a risk on a player from the Belgian league for £7m (Munoz) that's far less of a gamble than three times that much on Khalili. I would say the same about Canvot. It's notable enough to sign a player after only 19 senior games, to do it for £20m-odd takes it to a different level.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting I've pinpointed a clever equation or formula. Quite the opposite seems true. I'd reckon it's surely best to weigh all the different factors such as cost, age, sell on value, previous level of football, whether they've lived and played in England, for how long, etc and so on.

My concern is that the club seem a bit too willing to discard other important considerations to focus on age and sell on value.
He also had an extended spell in France as a beach
 
It was either Lacroix or Wharton, that had to be sold to comply with PSR rules. The January signings didn't work out as expected and Johnson turned out to be a disaster, apparently it was Glasner, who wanted him, so to placate him the club went along with it. The end result Glasner was motivated enough to lead us to the Conference League cup.
I think it was clear, splashing the cash like we did in January was a desperate attempt to get Ollie to stay, because it was so unlike us
 
  • Like
Reactions: Faz

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top