I know a lot is made of the recruitment, and there are certainly some big issues. One positive for me is that we are seemingly trying to sign a mix of experience and profiles. e.g. Khalali vs Mingueza. Chilwell vs Mitchell. Gozo/Osorio vs Sarr. One experienced and steady, the other more raw with hopefully greater potential.
For me the issues have stemmed from a couple of areas, and they intertwine:
Europe too early.
Over the last couple of years we've done really well in changing the dynamic of the squad, bringing the average down and ceiling of potential far higher. However, for the past couple of years the first 11 picks itself. To qualify for Europe via the league you need to prove the quality and depth of your squad over a season. We did amazingly well to win the FA cup, but in reality that was about 3 games. And having 90% of our first 11 fit when it mattered.
Fast forward and we are now in the 2nd season of Europe, and we've had to try, on a budget to deepen our squad to cope with the load. More numbers in, less to spend per player, more chances to make mistakes.
I suspect the need for experience and bodies to maximise the conference league opportunity was a big factor in going for Brennan Johnson.
Contracts and selling value
The Anderson/Lacroix deal was a example of it going perfectly. Sell a ageing star, at max value and recruit an almost as good guy, 5 years younger with a much higher ceiling. Short performance dip, but 20 games in new guy is settled. Munoz/Khalili may in time be another one....
But with Guehi, we got about a quarter of whats he's worth, Mateta will be the same. Sarr potentially too. I dont want to always bow to player power, but we need to do better at either extending contracts earlier OR selling earlier. 18 months in we should have been offering Guehi a bumper deal...it was clear where he was going. And if he didn't want to sign it we should have found a way of selling him at year 3.
Wharton will have 2 years left by the summer. Without extending, this summer he likely commands 70m, but moving forward that does down.
Wantaway players causing issues
The bad side of personal and club success is attracting suitors, and/or getting ideas above your station. JP in particular has caused us a huge issue. Kicked up so much of a fuss that the club were wiling to sell in Jan to protect some value. Everyone knows that JSL was overpriced, but with a backdrop of a manger kicking up a stink, needing a target man, wanting some prem experience etc net 15m for younger player probably had to be done. I suspect knowing JP was going also pushed the Johnson deal (appease Glasner by replacing JP with JSL and BJ).
JP obviously didn't go and BJ was beyond terrible. Now we'll struggle to recoup more than say £15m for JP, and we've wasted most of the season's transfer budget. The JSL deal should have been contingent on JP.