How’s your luck Marc?

[You What]

Wins the cup last year. Goes out the next game to lowest ranked team a top league club has lost to. Goes on to win it in the same season. Good luck to him!!!

 

[BromleyMonkey]

From one extreme to the other…..winner, worst defeat in fa cup history to winner again, can’t be bad 🤣

 

[Davepalace707]

What happened to being cup tied?

 

[eaglesdare]

I think we did him a favour not selling him to Newcastle and not selling him to Liverpool.

Also still on for a treble in the unlikely event that arsenal have a little wobble.

 

[Uphill]

Deserves every success going - he was a model player and person for us.
Hopefully he'll cap it off with a good World Cup.

 

[Phil’s Barber]

It just highlights how wrong the new rules are. Cup tied is a simple concept and is the correct process. You should not be able to play for two different teams in the same cup competition in the same season, especially when you’ve already been eliminated.

 

[Talvlad]

I bet he had more fun winning with Palace than with City

 

[eaglesdare]

It just highlights how wrong the new rules are. Cup tied is a simple concept and is the correct process. You should not be able to play for two different teams in the same cup competition in the same season, especially when you’ve already been eliminated.

I never liked the cup tied rule in the first place. I mean it would be the same as being league tied after playing for a different club in the league.

Simple solution is to scrap the January transfer window and close the summer window before the season kicks off 😃