Wilfried Zaha

Correct. Anyone saying Eze or Olise would be incorrect. They were both great but didn't lift the stadium as much as Wilf.

Agree - they will both clearly have better careers and you can make a case they are more rounded players (certainly in Olise’s case), but they didn’t have what Wilf did.

People moan about his ‘attitude’ but I can only imagine if you put half of Wilf’s competitiveness and desire to win into a more laid-back player like Eze.

It’s a huge part of what made him so special.
 
Not true.

As I said before if he was so great why no one want him (Bolazie was taken and many would say he was not as good yet his numbers at Palace was not much different to Wilf) and once he left look how that has turned out.

Our system was setup to go through him which is why we struggled but again people cherry picking stats we struggled with him as well.

At times I think people forget some of the players we have had and how they really made a difference Cabaye for example and then the solid people at the back like Cahill etc.
Wilf was a fantastic player for us and the most influential and important player in our history DESPITE and not because of the players around him. We had some decent players around then but without the GOAT we’d have been a basket case….
 
I just read the article about the possibility of a Wilf return...

I love Wilf, some fans talk about his attitude.. I don't care.. He was for, me the best, most iconic player of my time supporting Palace. Absolute legend for Palace.

So would I love to see him in the shirt again..... In a heart beat... NO...

He's 35 and hasn't played at a high level for a while. We need to be looking to the future, not the past. I don't believe his return would be a positive move.

It's not like he is a midfielder who can dictate the pace of a game, put through a killer pass or make a crucial tackle. His game was about the ability to get past a player to score or assist. I think that boat has sailed at Premier league level, I'm sad to say. I would love it if that wasn't the case but it is.

I'm sure I saw an interview some time ago where he himself said something like, Palace had moved on since his time at the club. So I think these reports would maybe even raise eyebrows in the Zaha household..

I would love to have him back in a backroom role but is that really Wilf? I doubt it.
 
My take on this is an emotionless one based on three questions:

1. Is WZ as good or better than what we have right now?
2. Will WZ be as good or better than what we are likely to have at the end of January?
3. If the answer to 1 and/or 2 is "yes", will WZ fit in to the new manager's plans?

Some factors to bear in mind:

a. We are at the tail end of November and the window will open in a few weeks.
b. We seem to lack direct running and pace up front this year.
c. I do not think we can rely on Sarr: he still seems to be sulking/injured/lining up another push for a move in January.
d. I do not think we can rely on Mateta: he is temperamental and it is possible he will also push for a move in January.
e. I do not think WZ would be a very positive influence around the place unless he is a starter more often than not.
f. Guessand seems out of favour.

I am not saying WZ solves any of the above necessarily but I think the above three questions should govern a decision on him looked at through a. to f. above.
 
Has he been training WITH the Club or AT the Club.
If it is true that he and Sage clashed during WF’s time in France I cannot believe PS would accept him training WITH his first team ?
 
It's a no from me. Other clubs have not been beating a path to his door which tells you all you need to know.

I don't think Zaha has the mentality to accept he is a fading star and to play the role of super sub.

I think this story is his agent reminding the world he is available.
 
No.

Arguably our GOAT, but in his final season, most fans were at the point where they knew it was time for him to go, as he'd lost a yard of pace and his tantrums were becoming more commonplace than his goals or assists. And that was three years ago. My gut feeling is he'd get frustrated that he couldn't do what he used to do; opposition players would target him, knowing he'd get wound up, and it'd all become a bit embarrassing for him and us.

I doubt there is a Palace fan alive who wouldn't love to see some miracle whereby Zaha rises from the scrapheap to lead us to salvation, but this seems more like when AJ returned, made one appearance in the league cup and then retired.
 
Been a fan for over 65 years, and think Wilf was great for us, at first I thought no way would I want him back, a legend and did not want him the destroy his legacy. But now I am thinking would be a great moral boost for the team and fans, no transferer fee and would hope wages would not be an issue, why not? cant be worst than Pino
The same Pino who’s been arguably our player of the season so far?
 
Wilfred
Arguably our best ever player, and Palace through and through just like Jimmy Cannon.
I for one would love to see him waring the number Eleven again.
 
I love the guy and he's a huge reason to thank for our prolonged stay in the top flight.

But his skills, pace and power began to fade before he left us, plus injuries started to creep in. So I can't see him adding a huge amount. Obviously if it's a short term contract until the end of the season then maybe it's worthwhile... Unless the thinking is... Get Wilf in and let Sarr/JP leave!
 
The only question would be, is he still better than Eddie Nketiah. If the answer is yes, then sign him on a pay per play contract.

It's not like the club don't know his current level of ability.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top