What the hell is happening at our club ?

Our model has been centred around signing players, developing them and then cashing in on them - for two reasons - we need the money and we are not a “ destination club “ as Steve Parish puts it.

And that was working to an extent . But, Wharton aside, and maybe Henderson and Sarr to a degree , who else is there in our present squad ?

Strand Larsen we would be lucky to get our money back on ( how Chelsea turned a profit on the similar Delap , I’ll never know ! ), and we certainly copped a hit with Johnson.

Freedman was a tough act to follow. But I fail to see how the Palace hierarchy can look at Hobbs and conclude he’s doing even an average job.
Even Freedman made some bad calls. Esse was one but the really bad one was Nketiah. Big money for a poor player who has then been injured. For different reasons Riad has been a failure as well but you can’t put that one at Dougie’s door. What Freedman had was a few spectacular successes. Hobbs hasn’t had any so far
 
Even Freedman made some bad calls. Esse was one but the really bad one was Nketiah. Big money for a poor player who has then been injured. For different reasons Riad has been a failure as well but you can’t put that one at Dougie’s door. What Freedman had was a few spectacular successes. Hobbs hasn’t had any so far
Yes, agreed.

Nobody’s going to get it right all the time but percentage wise Hobbs is proving a disappointment in my opinion
 
I largely agree with this, but think these signings show us a few interesting things.

1. Eze, Guehi, Wharton, and Olise mostly had some good-level first team football under their belts when we bought them. They were stepping up to the EPL, but were not total novices. They had played a decent number of competitive games in England. They got better over time, but were largely just about good enough from the outset. A lot of those things are not true of Canvot, Osorio, Pino, Khalili, and certainly Gozo, just like they weren't true of Franca or even Esse. By definition a 'potential development' player is unproven, but there are degrees of risk, and we went for longer and longer shots over time: Players who had played far less football and/or at lower levels and/or outside of England. I don't know if that was us trying to be clever, or that there were less prospects in the championship, or value became harder to find, but it is very different.

2. Eze et al came into a settled squad with a core of solid senior players who were not going anywhere, and so would work hard to ensure Palace stayed in the league. I imagine that creates a culture. The new batch came in to a group in flux, where the better players felt they had achieved all they could with Palace and wanted to move onwards and upwards, possibly fairly so as they, unlike Dann, Ward, MacArthur etc, had all signed for a feeder club. The type of core to which young hopefuls are added makes a huge difference. We don't have to guess how much help a Dann or a Cahill would give to a Canvot - we have seen how much better he was with Lacroix.

3. If you add up the profits on the Olise, Guehi, Eze and (one day) Wharton batch, it will more than cover the flops like Franca. Now, we need at least two of Canvot, Osorio, Pino, Khalili, or Gozo to go for megabucks just to break even on the rest of them. The first batch gave us profits to reinvest or cover losses. The second batch seem unlikely to.

To me, the whole buy, develop, sell, begin again model is no more than OK at best. Overall it comes with as many inbuilt flaws as trying to get by on journeymen. We couldn't have hit gold more solidly than we did with the Eze batch, and it still hasn't changed our world. We are not really much better off than we were with the journeymen. League place is much the same, and we were minutes away from winning the FA cup in 2016, so not as if even that success can be put down to the new model.
Good post and agree with all of this apart from the cup final in 2016. Our defence was more solid in 2025 and we were imo set up better against City with better defensive players. And we didn’t concede at the end when under pressure.
 
Yes, agreed.

Nobody’s going to get it right all the time but percentage wise Hobbs is proving a disappointment in my opinion
It is possible Osorio, Canvot, Khalaili, and Gozo will come good once they’re given a chance in an organised team. If so we may eventually sing Hobbs’ praises, but for the moment there are 3 significant strikes against his name. Firstly signing JSL on the assumption JP was going, secondly selling Lacroix on the assumption Ordonez was coming, and thirdly signing Johnson full stop. Three strikes and you’re out in my book.
 
It is possible Osorio, Canvot, Khalaili, and Gozo will come good once they’re given a chance in an organised team. If so we may eventually sing Hobbs’ praises, but for the moment there are 3 significant strikes against his name. Firstly signing JSL on the assumption JP was going, secondly selling Lacroix on the assumption Ordonez was coming, and thirdly signing Johnson full stop. Three strikes and you’re out in my book.
My understanding is that we had to sell Lacroix or Wharton simply to stay within the SCR rules given what we splurged in January
 
So what is happening to our club? Is it Frank? Or has he seen the light. It’s not a job without risk. Or is this just more of the snails pace business progress so often associated with the club.
 
One of the reasons why people are so disillusioned with the Premier League is the sheer imbalace of the competition.

It means a player like Eze, who would be one of the first names on the teamsheet at Palace, is one of the last names on the teamsheets at Arsenal.

The big clubs have ridiculously bloated squads with rarely featuring players who would be guaranteed starters at Palace.

It leads to situations, as someone alluded to earlier, where Chelsea can take our best centre back in Lacroix and leave us with one of theirs who they have been trying to offload for a couple of seasons (Disasi) and a youngster they are looking for us to develop on their behalf (Ahanor).

It leads to Liverpool feeling entitled to try and pinch Sarr for £40 million while selling Gakpo at twice the price.

I don't have a solution and if anything feel it will get rather worse.
I have stated before, that teams that are not part of the top 6 are just fodder for them to play against. As soon as people come to the same conclusion, they will realise we aren't going to be one of the elite clubs, that top players want to play for.
Players are basically for hire to the top bidder, the old days of players being loyal to one club are long gone. Everyone of them, would move to a bigger club, given the chance.
 
Excellent point well made!!😎

As I keep saying, at least we can all die happy whatever the outcome of the next few seasons

I’ve said to my Mrs if I go before her, I want “12th again, who gives a f*** we won the FA Cup” on my grave stone

We're destined to finish 13th that season and you'll have passers by thinking you're a Leeds fan.
 
I would be more upset if we went down with nothing to show for 13 years in the top league.
Me too. Controversial i know but personally i dont care massively if we do go down this season. We won 3 trophies and are owned by billionaires (although you wouldnt know it). Got the sleeper train down last night and been to Selhurst to get my picture with our haul of trophies. Get Lacey and Hobbs out and Freedman back and one day we might add to them, you never know. Id rather not get relegated obvs as bouncing back is never guaranteed, but i never thought we would win one thing, let alone three! If watching this defence leak 2 each week is the price im comfortable with it.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_2026-11-13-13-14-40-17_45e686c594768066ad9911d54d96f72b.webp
    Screenshot_2026-11-13-13-14-40-17_45e686c594768066ad9911d54d96f72b.webp
    82.6 KB · Views: 12
  • Screenshot_2026-11-13-13-11-34-05_45e686c594768066ad9911d54d96f72b.webp
    Screenshot_2026-11-13-13-11-34-05_45e686c594768066ad9911d54d96f72b.webp
    110.3 KB · Views: 12
I largely agree with this, but think these signings show us a few interesting things.

1. Eze, Guehi, Wharton, and Olise mostly had some good-level first team football under their belts when we bought them. They were stepping up to the EPL, but were not total novices. They had played a decent number of competitive games in England. They got better over time, but were largely just about good enough from the outset. A lot of those things are not true of Canvot, Osorio, Pino, Khalili, and certainly Gozo, just like they weren't true of Franca or even Esse. By definition a 'potential development' player is unproven, but there are degrees of risk, and we went for longer and longer shots over time: Players who had played far less football and/or at lower levels and/or outside of England. I don't know if that was us trying to be clever, or that there were less prospects in the championship, or value became harder to find, but it is very different.

2. Eze et al came into a settled squad with a core of solid senior players who were not going anywhere, and so would work hard to ensure Palace stayed in the league. I imagine that creates a culture. The new batch came in to a group in flux, where the better players felt they had achieved all they could with Palace and wanted to move onwards and upwards, possibly fairly so as they, unlike Dann, Ward, MacArthur etc, had all signed for a feeder club. The type of core to which young hopefuls are added makes a huge difference. We don't have to guess how much help a Dann or a Cahill would give to a Canvot - we have seen how much better he was with Lacroix.

3. If you add up the profits on the Olise, Guehi, Eze and (one day) Wharton batch, it will more than cover the flops like Franca. Now, we need at least two of Canvot, Osorio, Pino, Khalili, or Gozo to go for megabucks just to break even on the rest of them. The first batch gave us profits to reinvest or cover losses. The second batch seem unlikely to.

To me, the whole buy, develop, sell, begin again model is no more than OK at best. Overall it comes with as many inbuilt flaws as trying to get by on journeymen. We couldn't have hit gold more solidly than we did with the Eze batch, and it still hasn't changed our world. We are not really much better off than we were with the journeymen. League place is much the same, and we were minutes away from winning the FA cup in 2016, so not as if even that success can be put down to the new model.

I get the intention of this point but (without debating the value of experience and level of different leagues) Pino, Khalali and Osorio are full Internationals. With bags of experience.

On signing, Wharton had about half a season, Guehi a season, Olise a season and a half of experience. Eze was the only one with multiple seasons under his belt. It a bit of a miracle that all have progressed to international level.

The thing we need to remember is that Eze and Olise didnt come in and start performing straight away. From memory Jordan Ayew took a while to be displaced.
 
Me too. Controversial i know but personally i dont care massively if we do go down this season. We won 3 trophies and are owned by billionaires (although you wouldnt know it). Got the sleeper train down last night and been to Selhurst to get my picture with our haul of trophies. Get Lacey and Hobbs out and Freedman back and one day we might add to them, you never know. Id rather not get relegated obvs as bouncing back is never guaranteed, but i never thought we would win one thing, let alone three! If watching this defence leak 2 each week is the price im comfortable with it.
What's Ally McCoist doing there?
 
Is the Premier League getting better or the Championship getting worse.
I pose the question because much has justifiably made of our transfer record from that division with Olise, Eze, Wharton and Guehi ( Chelsea, but scouted when on loan at Swansea.

However, when I look more recently at us (Esse) and other Premier Clubs there have been no resounding successes making the step up.
I look at Dibbling and Hackney ( (Everton), Azeez ( Brighton), Charles (Fulham), and Fatawu ( Ipswich) and none of them made much of an impact to date.
We were linked with four of these players ourselves.

It’s an accepted wisdom that we should mine the Championship for talent in an effort to replicate previous success, but perhaps it’s not as easy as it sounds.
 
One of the reasons why people are so disillusioned with the Premier League is the sheer imbalace of the competition.

It means a player like Eze, who would be one of the first names on the teamsheet at Palace, is one of the last names on the teamsheets at Arsenal.

The big clubs have ridiculously bloated squads with rarely featuring players who would be guaranteed starters at Palace.

It leads to situations, as someone alluded to earlier, where Chelsea can take our best centre back in Lacroix and leave us with one of theirs who they have been trying to offload for a couple of seasons (Disasi) and a youngster they are looking for us to develop on their behalf (Ahanor).

It leads to Liverpool feeling entitled to try and pinch Sarr for £40 million while selling Gakpo at twice the price.

I don't have a solution and if anything feel it will get rather worse.

Unfortuently there is no solution.

Every time a mid table team does well, and develops a good bunch their teams will get picked apart. Its not just us. Brentford loosing their front 3, Brighton selling to Chelsea, Bournemouth losing their whole defence.

The hope, (Bournmouth and Brighton are potentially proving the model now) is that constant recruitment and reinvestment means you are happy to sell for big fees as you have the replacement all ready to go, and whilst there might be short dips, you are getting stronger over time.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top