welcome to Brennan Johnson

Thomas Frank whilst manager of Tottenham commented that Johnson is very good at arriving in the box, very good at running in behind defences and opined that these were his key strengths.
Much earlier, Neil Warnock commented that he is a player who gets supporters off their seats when he is in possession of the ball.
We have clearly not seen the best version of Brennan Johnson.
 
kevlee said:
You are way out!!
His wages are reported to be between £4.2m - £5.7m pa!!
We were mugged off big time. In a normal company whoever signed off this deal would have been sacked.
Click to expand...
Nketiah, Franca, Johnson - 3 deals that show that something is wrong in whoever is behind player acquisition. A giveaway is when the selling club is happy to release the player, and £20/30m keeps things ticking over nicely. In the case of Nketiah, we paid nigh on £30m whilst Arsenal later got Eze from us for going on £67.5m, so in reality we let Eze go for under £40m, as Nketiah has shown what many knew, he's not very good...
Franca the less said the better.
Johnson, nothing to show that he's worth even half what we paid thus far, no skill, no presence, just a little bit of pace but I recall Usain Bolt fancied himself as a player once upon a time.
 
park the bus said:
Nketiah, Franca, Johnson - 3 deals that show that something is wrong in whoever is behind player acquisition. A giveaway is when the selling club is happy to release the player, and £20/30m keeps things ticking over nicely. In the case of Nketiah, we paid nigh on £30m whilst Arsenal later got Eze from us for going on £67.5m, so in reality we let Eze go for under £40m, as Nketiah has shown what many knew, he's not very good...
Franca the less said the better.
Johnson, nothing to show that he's worth even half what we paid thus far, no skill, no presence, just a little bit of pace but I recall Usain Bolt fancied himself as a player once upon a time.
Click to expand...
As I mentioned on HOL, I had seen Nketiah on Loan at Leeds and saw no reason to sing his praises.
I was thunderstruck when we signed Nketiah for £25 Mill rising to £30 Mill.
 
Willo said:
Thomas Frank whilst manager of Tottenham commented that Johnson is very good at arriving in the box, very good at running in behind defences and opined that these were his key strengths.
Much earlier, Neil Warnock commented that he is a player who gets supporters off their seats when he is in possession of the ball.
We have clearly not seen the best version of Brennan Johnson.
Click to expand...

Frank's summary is quite accurate. He's a poor man's Sarr. Not great against a low block, and lacks the individual skills to beat his man, but when there is a high line is good at getting behind and has pace to burn.

The issue for him, and us, is that Sarr is just better at the role.
 
palace99 said:
Frank's summary is quite accurate. He's a poor man's Sarr. Not great against a low block, and lacks the individual skills to beat his man, but when there is a high line is good at getting behind and has pace to burn.

The issue for him, and us, is that Sarr is just better at the role.
Click to expand...
Towards the end of the 22-23 season, he recorded the fastest time in the PL that campaign at just shy of 23 MPH.
 
Will never understand why fans are so keep to write players off so quickly.

Especially as time after time, players written off early come good.

Be open minded, maybe there is more to come 🙂
 
MrRobbo said:
Will never understand why fans are so keep to write players off so quickly.

Especially as time after time, players written off early come good.

Be open minded, maybe there is more to come 🙂
Click to expand...
In think in this case it is partly driven by the aforementioned signings of Nketiah and Franca.
In the cases of Nketiah and Johnson a lot of fans were expressing incredulity at what we were paying. But what do we know….
 
Johnson is emblematic of the issues we face whenever trying to strengthen the side by buying big 'proven' EPL top flight players, rather than by developing unproven players from lower leagues, the academy, or aboard.

Previous examples of big money buys who were either supposed to take us to the 'next level' or at least provide a quality-for-quality replacement for an outgoing star man include Benteke, Sakho, Cabeye, Nketiah, Andersen, and Townsend. How many of them get in your all-time XI? Or even your best XI from the last ten years?

1. Any such player is almost bound to be too expensive, in terms of the actual sum and also value. The 'next level' looks like where we are now, a cup win and a lesser European competition. Neither brings in very much money, at least not compared to the cost of tyring to build a 'next level' side. If buying these players is to get us to that level, then the numbers simply do not add up.

2. Any such player is very often stepping down to Palace from a bigger club. I always thought a lot of the players listed above seemed demotivated by a move that probably signals the end of their personal rise. I'm sure they are all very professional, but that's not the same as being hungry. Human beings are what they are, whatever you pay them.

3. Often they can't be sold on for even the same fee we paid, let alone for a profit. Not only are we stuck with them if they underperform, we have often spent so much that we have very little left to play with in seeking an alternative player for their position. Usually buying 'proven' means less of a gamble. In this context, though, its a huge risk for us.

Turning to Johnson, not only has he not scored, he has been very poor in general play, in that he has been completely anonymous. If he was a kid from the youth team or a lower-league prospect, he would have been jettisoned to the reserves months ago, with the verdict that it was plainly all too much for him.

It's getting harder and harder to see that there might be a good player in there. If he gets a run in a different position and system next season, perhaps we will get something back from him, but it would increasingly be a big old surprise.

I've said it a few times now so I'm sorry for repeating myself, but to my mind the new managers first task, and the thing he should be grilled on at interview, is how he plans to get value out of the players we have spent big on, because we are very much stuck with them.
 
TheBigToePunt said:
Johnson is emblematic of the issues we face whenever trying to strengthen the side by buying big 'proven' EPL top flight players, rather than by developing unproven players from lower leagues, the academy, or aboard.

Previous examples of big money buys who were either supposed to take us to the 'next level' or at least provide a quality-for-quality replacement for an outgoing star man include Benteke, Sakho, Cabeye, Nketiah, Andersen, and Townsend. How many of them get in your all-time XI? Or even your best XI from the last ten years?

1. Any such player is almost bound to be too expensive, in terms of the actual sum and also value. The 'next level' looks like where we are now, a cup win and a lesser European competition. Neither brings in very much money, at least not compared to the cost of tyring to build a 'next level' side. If buying these players is to get us to that level, then the numbers simply do not add up.

2. Any such player is very often stepping down to Palace from a bigger club. I always thought a lot of the players listed above seemed demotivated by a move that probably signals the end of their personal rise. I'm sure they are all very professional, but that's not the same as being hungry. Human beings are what they are, whatever you pay them.

3. Often they can't be sold on for even the same fee we paid, let alone for a profit. Not only are we stuck with them if they underperform, we have often spent so much that we have very little left to play with in seeking an alternative player for their position. Usually buying 'proven' means less of a gamble. In this context, though, its a huge risk for us.

Turning to Johnson, not only has he not scored, he has been very poor in general play, in that he has been completely anonymous. If he was a kid from the youth team or a lower-league prospect, he would have been jettisoned to the reserves months ago, with the verdict that it was plainly all too much for him.

It's getting harder and harder to see that there might be a good player in there. If he gets a run in a different position and system next season, perhaps we will get something back from him, but it would increasingly be a big old surprise.

I've said it a few times now so I'm sorry for repeating myself, but to my mind the new managers first task, and the thing he should be grilled on at interview, is how he plans to get value out of the players we have spent big on, because we are very much stuck with them.
Click to expand...
I think I broadly agree with your arguments here about buying PL 'proven' quality players and that this would definitely apply to crazy legs Sakho and Benteke. Got to say I disagree about Cabaye, Anderson and Townsend, I think all three would get into my team of the last ten years. Cabaye especially had a class about him with his range of passing and general ability that made him stand out in the team of the time, certainly for a season or two. I am on the fence with Nketiah, I disagree with those who think hes cr@p but I also think we overpaid.
 
I do think the Eze's, Whartons and Olise's are the exception. And that can sway what good looks like.

We've done amazingly well to get them in, enjoy them (and in 2 cases) sell for a big profit.

But its not a foolproof model. There aren't tonnes of they players hanging around waiting to explode onto the scene.

So we need to raid the championship when we can, spend decent money on up and coming players (Canvot, Riad), bring in the experience (Kamada, Lerma), be decisive and spend big on important players (Larsson) and also take gambles on players when they become available for resonable fees (Hendo, Johnson, Nketiah).

It was only a couple of weeks ago that Canvot and Riad were slated. And now after a bit of patience are looking like they could both develop into elite level defenders.

With Johnson specifically, he plays wide, chalk on boots wide. This system under OG wont get the best of him. New manager in the summer might change that. Regardless he'll learn new formations and positions over time.
 
MrRobbo said:
I do think the Eze's, Whartons and Olise's are the exception. And that can sway what good looks like.

We've done amazingly well to get them in, enjoy them (and in 2 cases) sell for a big profit.

But its not a foolproof model. There aren't tonnes of they players hanging around waiting to explode onto the scene.

So we need to raid the championship when we can, spend decent money on up and coming players (Canvot, Riad), bring in the experience (Kamada, Lerma), be decisive and spend big on important players (Larsson) and also take gambles on players when they become available for resonable fees (Hendo, Johnson, Nketiah).

It was only a couple of weeks ago that Canvot and Riad were slated. And now after a bit of patience are looking like they could both develop into elite level defenders.

With Johnson specifically, he plays wide, chalk on boots wide. This system under OG wont get the best of him. New manager in the summer might change that. Regardless he'll learn new formations and positions over time.
Click to expand...
In League One, I am led to believe that central defender Dylan Lawlor (Cardiff) is on the 'radar' of top clubs across Europe.
 
Franca cost c.£22m
Nketia c.£25m
Johnson c. £35m
Larson c.£45m

That is c. £130m. What would we get back on them if we went to sell them tomorrow.
My guess is we would be lucky to see £60m all in.
That tells me whoever is involved in finding and securing new players needs to be moved aside.
There are plenty of people on here who could do a better job.
 
MrRobbo said:
Will never understand why fans are so keep to write players off so quickly.

Especially as time after time, players written off early come good.

Be open minded, maybe there is more to come 🙂
Click to expand...
i don't think anyone has written Johnson off, however, many have quite reasonably expressed concerns at both his performances and his inability to influence games.

He is not a young player coming from abroad (as per your Canvot example) he is a British based player with a reasonable amount of premier league and international experience.

Furthermore we paid a significant amount of money for him and he is one of our top earners.

As i said earlier i think his confidence is shot and i can't see this changing in the short term, however, after a rest and a decent pre-season hopefully next year we will see a better player.

Incidentally, i don't consider him an out and out winger. At Forest where he played his best football, he often moved across the forward line and scored a lot of his goals drifting in behind the defence.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top