Russell Brand

Blocked.

If anyone is going to suggest that because I disagree that the evidence threshold for rape hasn't been met in this case somehow means that I somehow support rape or some fecked up variation of that meaning then they aren't worth the time.

Misrepsenting an incredibly damning text exchange to try and make a rapist seem more innocent is indeed 'fecked up'.

As I said, I can only speculate on why someone would feel the need to do that.
 
Misrepsenting an incredibly damning text exchange to try and make a rapist seem more innocent is indeed 'fecked up'.

As I said, I can only speculate on why someone would feel the need to do that.

These free speech champions really can’t cope with others using their own free speech to challenge them, can they?

It’s obvious to anyone reading this thread what Stirling’s position is. He’s said multiple times that he doesn’t consider this ‘real rape’.
 
Brand is a wrong 'un but It's the broader implications which need to be considered. Once again how can any man defend himself against an accusation that sleeping with someone 27 years ago wasn't consensual especially if it was to start with? How many people who had a one night stand in the past are open to the same treatment?

The same way Brand managed to defend himself against the other allegations in this exact trial.

If a jury already convicting him of rape and sexual assault still found him not guilty of other rapes, it surely makes a nonsense of any argument that there is no possible defence on these sort of charges, or indeed that guilty verdicts are handed out for fun in these cases.

A group of 12, knowing he's a rapist and sexual abuser, still didn't find him guilty on the other charges - if a convicted rapist and sexual abuser can get off these charges, pretending it's some impossible threshold to meet is just nonsense.
 
The same way Brand managed to defend himself against the other allegations in this exact trial.

If a jury already convicting him of rape and sexual assault still found him not guilty of other rapes, it surely makes a nonsense of any argument that there is no possible defence on these sort of charges, or indeed that guilty verdicts are handed out for fun in these cases.

A group of 12, knowing he's a rapist and sexual abuser, still didn't find him guilty on the other charges - if a convicted rapist and sexual abuser can get off these charges, pretending it's some impossible threshold to meet is just nonsense.
OK, well bear that in mind if it happens to someone you know.
 
So (if true) RB took off the condom and continued against her will but was already having sex with her that was not against her will.

There is more to the one rape conviction than appears.

😎
 
So (if true) RB took off the condom and continued against her will but was already having sex with her that was not against her will.

There is more to the one rape conviction than appears.

😎

I regard the word 'rape' to mean some force was used to make an act happen.

I am of course aware that the legal definition is wider ranging, just as it is for the word 'assault'.....but personally I regard that as bad law and acts that don't involve violence should be given a different category because (while wrong) they are a lesser offence.

But we are long past the time where opinions like that can be aired without insane reactions.

If we take what the woman said was true (and I don't regard that threshold to be met), then Brand is being called a rapist for not only taking the condom off (bad show) but essentially taking his knob out of one hole and putting it into another, she saying 'no' and him continuing.

For me, that isn't what I consider rape to the extent that you put someone in a cell for ten years, 23 hours of the day......It's very wrong, but unless she struggled to remove it, then just saying 'no' can be interpreted differently during sex....as sex can be fecked up....literally.

But I would regard it as an offence, if true.

Like I said, Brand deserved a punch in the gob.....as for the women, she entered into casual sex with a known degenerate and I don't trust the word of people like that. If she had said, I struggled to make him stop but he forced me into anal sex.....then yes, I would regard that as rape....if it happened.
 
I regard the word 'rape' to mean some force was used to make an act happen.

I am of course aware that the legal definition is wider ranging, just as it is for the word 'assault'.....but personally I regard that as bad law and acts that don't involve violence should be given a different category because (while wrong) they are a lesser offence.

But we are long past the time where opinions like that can be aired without insane reactions.

If we take what the woman said was true (and I don't regard that threshold to be met), then Brand is being called a rapist for not only taking the condom off (bad show) but essentially taking his knob out of one hole and putting it into another, she saying 'no' and him continuing.

For me, that isn't what I consider rape to the extent that you put someone in a cell for ten years, 23 hours of the day......It's very wrong, but unless she struggled to remove it, then just saying 'no' can be interpreted differently during sex....as sex can be fecked up....literally.

But I would regard it as an offence, if true.

Like I said, Brand deserved a punch in the gob.....as for the women, she entered into casual sex with a known degenerate and I don't trust the word of people like that. If she had said, I struggled to make him stop but he forced me into anal sex.....then yes, I would regard that as rape....if it happened.
It does though, make a 10 year jail sentence out of all proportion imo..

😎
 
So (if true) RB took off the condom and continued against her will but was already having sex with her that was not against her will.

There is more to the one rape conviction than appears.

😎

Yes, consent can be withdrawn at any time - that's literally how the law works.

What's the alternative? Once someone starts having sex they can't then ask to stop or change their mind..?

Scary, scary stuff this.
 
These free speech champions really can’t cope with others using their own free speech to challenge them, can they?

It’s obvious to anyone reading this thread what Stirling’s position is. He’s said multiple times that he doesn’t consider this ‘real rape’.

"...Brand is being called a rapist for not only taking the condom off (bad show) but essentially taking his knob out of one hole and putting it into another, she saying 'no' and him continuing.
For me, that isn't what I consider rape to the extent that you put someone in a cell for ten years"

Genuinely unbelievable.
 
Yes, consent can be withdrawn at any time - that's literally how the law works.

What's the alternative? Once someone starts having sex they can't then ask to stop or change their mind..?

Scary, scary stuff this.
If it bears repeating this is not a defence of rapists but what evidence can be presented decades later?
 
If it bears repeating this is not a defence of rapists but what evidence can be presented decades later?

In isolation, hardly anything, which is why you see next to none of those type of convictions.

But when you have dozens of witnesses corroborating the same decades-old story, as well as supporting evidence from a healthcare professional, and text messages etc. etc. ... all of the adds up to a very convincing case.
 
In isolation, hardly anything, which is why you see next to none of those type of convictions.

But when you have dozens of witnesses corroborating the same decades-old story, as well as supporting evidence from a healthcare professional, and text messages etc. etc. ... all of the adds up to a very convincing case.
Right, but I know of a friend's son who was similarly accused, in his case wrongly, and it nearly destroyed him.
 
A very touching message read out by his wife to the media. And as always, insanely funny.
Really troubling that , not only does he publicly denounce the court system at his trial, but that he also considers himself a comedian. Both, highly improbable.

And also reported that Brand has recently put his properties into his wife's name. Obviously pending potential Civil claims for damages where the burden of proof threshold would be "more likely than not".
 
Yes, consent can be withdrawn at any time - that's literally how the law works.

What's the alternative? Once someone starts having sex they can't then ask to stop or change their mind..?

Scary, scary stuff this.
Chastity belt sales are gonna go through the roof this Christmas party season!!
 
I regard the word 'rape' to mean some force was used to make an act happen.

I am of course aware that the legal definition is wider ranging, just as it is for the word 'assault'.....but personally I regard that as bad law and acts that don't involve violence should be given a different category because (while wrong) they are a lesser offence.

But we are long past the time where opinions like that can be aired without insane reactions.

If we take what the woman said was true (and I don't regard that threshold to be met), then Brand is being called a rapist for not only taking the condom off (bad show) but essentially taking his knob out of one hole and putting it into another, she saying 'no' and him continuing.

For me, that isn't what I consider rape to the extent that you put someone in a cell for ten years, 23 hours of the day......It's very wrong, but unless she struggled to remove it, then just saying 'no' can be interpreted differently during sex....as sex can be fecked up....literally.

But I would regard it as an offence, if true.

Like I said, Brand deserved a punch in the gob.....as for the women, she entered into casual sex with a known degenerate and I don't trust the word of people like that. If she had said, I struggled to make him stop but he forced me into anal sex.....then yes, I would regard that as rape....if it happened.

It doesn't matter what your opinion is on laws or what you class as something to mean.

If it is defined in the law no matter what your view otherwise believes.

Consent was given for sex with a condom not without and the same for going into another hole that means both those acts was non consensual.

She said yes to one act the first not the other 2 which she claims to have said no to.

Not sure why you are having such difficulty understanding this do you have some sort of learning disorder?

nonconsensual = rape for your simple brain.
 
I regard the word 'rape' to mean some force was used to make an act happen.

I am of course aware that the legal definition is wider ranging, just as it is for the word 'assault'.....but personally I regard that as bad law and acts that don't involve violence should be given a different category because (while wrong) they are a lesser offence.

But we are long past the time where opinions like that can be aired without insane reactions.

If we take what the woman said was true (and I don't regard that threshold to be met), then Brand is being called a rapist for not only taking the condom off (bad show) but essentially taking his knob out of one hole and putting it into another, she saying 'no' and him continuing.

For me, that isn't what I consider rape to the extent that you put someone in a cell for ten years, 23 hours of the day......It's very wrong, but unless she struggled to remove it, then just saying 'no' can be interpreted differently during sex....as sex can be fecked up....literally.

But I would regard it as an offence, if true.

Like I said, Brand deserved a punch in the gob.....as for the women, she entered into casual sex with a known degenerate and I don't trust the word of people like that. If she had said, I struggled to make him stop but he forced me into anal sex.....then yes, I would regard that as rape....if it happened.

I think this is an interesting point.

My sympathy for the women might be lessend, or perhaps there is some judgement on my side. It's a bit like the analogy of less sympathy for someone who gets mugged whilst waving cash around at night in a notoriously crime-ridden neighbourhood in comparison to some poor soul who is preyed upon in a very ordinary circumstance.

The crime is still the crime however. So whilst Brand may not have dragged women down alleyways in the dark of night, he is a degenerate who at the very least has made it very hard to disbelieve that he's accused of. Him paying for that seems just and right in my eyes and if my sympathy for the victims is slightly lessened to other cases, my sympathy for him is zero.

Yes the ability to prove categorcially, beyond any doubt, that Brand did what he was accused of is difficult to meet (as with most rape cases), it does seem as though he is lying in his own bed now given the sheer volume behind the accusations. I'm still convinced that which he has been convicted of may only be a drop in the ocean, but that's just my opinon.

If there was zero evidence and merely anecdotal accusations against a completely upstanding individual, I'd be outraged on their behalf. I don't think that's the case here however.

We can never know the full truth but on the balance of things, I won't lose any sleep. The surrounding arguments are still valid, but I don't think I know any bloke who's demonstrated the kind of behaviour Brand has. If I did and they found themselves in trouble, I wouldn't fight their corner that's for sure. He was in a relationship with a 16 year old girl when he was 30. That's a death sentence in some male circles.

I think most importantly, the things being considered as little 'this or that's' he did during consensual sex are not anything I would not even consider doing, from a moral standpoint if nothing else, so that says a lot for me and again, I won't have any sympathy for him being done for 'rape'.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top