• Existing user of old message board?

    Your username will have transferred over to this new message board, but your password will need to be reset. Visit our convert your account page, to transfer your old password over.

Nketiah?

Lanzo-Ad

Lanzo-Ad

Member
Location
Lanzarote
Country
Spain
This is a list of current players, playing centre forward, premier league only, goals per minute, info from Transfermarkt:
Calvert-Lewin 276
Solanke 274
Jiminez 246
Rashford 239
Welbeck 236
Hojlund 235
Watkins 211
Wood 210
Nketiah 210
Mateta 181

The guy deserves a decent run with JP in a front 2, he is better than people think, i rate him highly in that position. he deserves more than the 156 minutes he has played at CF in the Premier this season.
 
It was an odd signing and I think most of us were asking why the club have spent 25-30 million on a striker when we had one of the most in form strikers in Europe and only play one up front. I think you might be right that we should at least give it a go with two up top although a lot will depend on who is actually fit in two weeks time. If it's a hamstring then I'm not sure Nketiah will be fit.
 
Lanzo-Ad said:
This is a list of current players, playing centre forward, premier league only, goals per minute, info from Transfermarkt:
Calvert-Lewin 276
Solanke 274
Jiminez 246
Rashford 239
Welbeck 236
Hojlund 235
Watkins 211
Wood 210
Nketiah 210
Mateta 181

The guy deserves a decent run with JP in a front 2, he is better than people think, i rate him highly in that position. he deserves more than the 156 minutes he has played at CF in the Premier this season.
Click to expand...
Genuine question. What makes you think he is better than the consensus view? What have you seen this season or before that makes you think that? As I say genuinely interested in your view
 
JHB said:
Genuine question. What makes you think he is better than the consensus view? What have you seen this season or before that makes you think that? As I say genuinely interested in your view
Click to expand...
I think he is a natural goal scorer, AJ style, one position man, CF, he is quick and intelligent and will get goals , him and Mateta as a pair should be the starting point of the team line-up, bit more direct, but OG, knows best.
 
Lanzo-Ad said:
I think he is a natural goal scorer, AJ style, one position man, CF, he is quick and intelligent and will get goals , him and Mateta as a pair should be the starting point of the team line-up, bit more direct, but OG, knows best.
Click to expand...
Thanks. So would you go 4-4-2 then? In that system I think we’d have to invest in at least 2 more wide players in January as right now the squad has only one in Sarr. Of course many of us thought a wide player should have been a priority in the summer but here we are.
 
NEILLO said:
I always considered Nketiah to be a penalty box type player.

I've barely seen him in that area for Palace.

At the moment he looks to me like another square peg in a round hole.
Click to expand...
If he is going to play it has to be up top. However, he quite clearly offers much less than Mateta in terms of overall play. So we’ve basically spent £25m on a player who was always going to be on the bench or out of position. Just bonkers business.

For me it says a lot that Arsenal are clearly desperately crying out for a penalty box forward who can finish yet snapped our hand off to be rid of Nketiah.
 
JHB said:
If he is going to play it has to be up top. However, he quite clearly offers much less than Mateta in terms of overall play. So we’ve basically spent £25m on a player who was always going to be on the bench or out of position. Just bonkers business.

For me it says a lot that Arsenal are clearly desperately crying out for a penalty box forward who can finish yet snapped our hand off to be rid of Nketiah.
Click to expand...
It looks that way at the moment.

I can only see Nketiah being effective alongside another striker.
 
NEILLO said:
It looks that way at the moment.

I can only see Nketiah being effective alongside another striker.
Click to expand...
I think you have hit the nail on the head there: he doesn't look like the kind of player who would work consistently as a lone striker but we are unlikely to play with two up. It begs the question of how he fits in to any OG starting XI.
 
I actually don't think he's a bad signing, he offers something different to mateta and would strengthen most squads in the bottom half. The problem is his price tag, we're not a club who's paying 30 mill for a player to sit on the bench, so we're forced to play him out of position. There's no way he starts in front of mateta due to the physical attributes of mateta.

We've been rumored to have been looking at him for a while but he was on his way to forest before they pulled out of the deal, so it was just another panic buy from the club.
 
I for one haven't written him off yet.

But for Glenn Murray and his 30 goals we almost certainly wouldn't have been promoted in season 2012/2013. However, in the his first season with us in 11/12 he scored a meagre 6 goals in the league and was often only on the subs bench in the 2nd half of the season.

Players don't always click immediately.
 
This bloke is no Glen Murray and all the arsenal fans I know can't believe they got that much for a very average player.
 
imashed said:
This bloke is no Glen Murray and all the arsenal fans I know can't believe they got that much for a very average player.
Click to expand...
That's my point ... the Glenn Murray we remember is the Glenn Murray from our promotion winning season, not from the season before when he was ineffective.

Whether Nketiah will come good or not none of us really know, but I'm not giving up on him yet.
 
So what do we do with Nketiah, was he bought to replace Mateta if he wants to leave, if Mateta doesn't and we give him a new contract, we have Nketiah for 5 years on 90k a week, he can only really play CF, and i don't see him playing, i would think Glasner might put Sarr at CF, if Mateta is injured, do we try and offload him in Jan, while his stock is reasonably high, he must be the unnamed player when Glasner says we cant make the same mistake again in the next window?
 
If we buy Saka, Martinelli, Trossard and Odegard in the January window there's a possibility that Nketiah will finally come alive with the improved service.
 
Lanzo-Ad said:
So what do we do with Nketiah, was he bought to replace Mateta if he wants to leave, if Mateta doesn't and we give him a new contract, we have Nketiah for 5 years on 90k a week, he can only really play CF, and i don't see him playing, i would think Glasner might put Sarr at CF, if Mateta is injured, do we try and offload him in Jan, while his stock is reasonably high, he must be the unnamed player when Glasner says we cant make the same mistake again in the next window?
Click to expand...
No chance of us offloading in January. Wouldn’t be a market for him so we’d take a big loss on any deal. We’d also need to then bring in another forward in a hurry so would probably have to pay over the odds. We will hold on to him and hope he comes good. Deal was silly in spending £25m on a player who doesn’t justify a place in the first team but we are stuck with it now.
 
Lanzo-Ad said:
So what do we do with Nketiah, was he bought to replace Mateta if he wants to leave, if Mateta doesn't and we give him a new contract, we have Nketiah for 5 years on 90k a week, he can only really play CF, and i don't see him playing, i would think Glasner might put Sarr at CF, if Mateta is injured, do we try and offload him in Jan, while his stock is reasonably high, he must be the unnamed player when Glasner says we cant make the same mistake again in the next window?
Click to expand...

Its hard to know what to do with him.

He's not as bad as people are making out. He has always been a goal scorer, and has a decent record when he plays. But not sure he can do it on the right wing in a team that has to defend a fair bit.

Might have to bide his time for a bit. We've been pretty lucky with JPMs fitness so far, but there will be times this season where we'll need him to lead the line.
 
MrRobbo said:
Its hard to know what to do with him.

He's not as bad as people are making out. He has always been a goal scorer, and has a decent record when he plays. But not sure he can do it on the right wing in a team that has to defend a fair bit.

Might have to bide his time for a bit. We've been pretty lucky with JPMs fitness so far, but there will be times this season where we'll need him to lead the line.
Click to expand...
It Mateta doesn't sign a contract in the close season, then he will have to be sold, surely the days are gone when a wanted player is allowed to leave for nothing, step forward Nketiah
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Share this page

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top