The Brexit thread

Burnham is enhancing his reputation as someone who actually gets things done.

Useful things, not major, that will help our people cope better with the brexit general incompetence of the tory years.

😎

If by getting things done you mean talking a load of incorrect statistics about Brexit, you might be right.

Starmer did most of this 'Brexit reset' anyway and when you look at the effect of it it's not clear whether these changes will benefit us slightly or worsen us slightly.

Burnham talks down Brexit, yet the British economy has been doing better than Germany's or France's over the last few years.....which isn't saying much due to the cost of living, but it's true.
 
At the end of the day it's just some footloose and fancy free young people looking to work behind a bar or washing pots , picking grapes or bleeding asparagus... big deal , don't know what all the fuss is about .
 
Why not put it to the people if they have a majority? Unless it’s only 52%/48%, which we all know isn’t enough.
Interesting that the EU are seriously considering Rwanda, wonder how the EU whipping boy Burnham will sell that to his party
For the reason I gave above. Demographics.

Only 33% currently think Brexit was a good idea. They are from every age and gender but, let's face it, the majority are from the retired population, substantively male.

Meanwhile, 55% of those polled say it is a bad idea. They are more likely to be in employment i.e. younger with more female representation.

The statistical issue. Every man jack of the older male population votes. Meanwhile, there is a lower propensity for "Remain" voters to turn up. Hence, the current 55/33 split is likely to translate as an apparently closer vote. In 2016, the 52/48 split was wholly misleading on what "the people" wanted, but it was an accurate snap shot of what those who voted wanted.

The other point, of course, is that 55 and 33 do not add up to 100. 12% fall into the "don't know" category. Many can be dismissed as, by expressing "don't know" they mean "don't care" and probably won't vote.

But many are also genuinely undecided and can swing depending on the "quality" of the campaign. If you really can't decide one way or the other by now, you are not the brightest tack in the box. These voters are more likely to be moved by simple two-line populist campaigns that won Leave the Referendum. They are also more vulnerable to foreign interference that was used the last time round. It was not decisive then, but it may be this time.

Thus, the split has to be much better than 55/33. It will need to be closer to a sustained two thirds, something that may happen if the nation's insecurities increase and we appear stronger inside the EU than out of it. With the Ruskies breathing down our necks, I suspect most will care a great deal less about sovereignty and Polish builders.

Meanwhile, Burnham is a politician. He can see that the majority want to go back in but he can't cross the manifesto red lines. So, he will get as near to those lines as he possibly can. Hence today.

Kemi is also a politician. She is faced with a dilemma. The same one every Tory leader has faced since the War. After the Referendum, the party turned 180 degrees towards Brexit and purged itself of a significant number of MPs, primarily those who were able to spell their own name correctly. The bright ones who remained were Remainers who faked Leave thereby substituting public service for self service. However, if it is one thing they can all do and that is read polling and polling trajectory. Kemi is already receiving overtures from some in her party to, at least consider, a 180 degree change back to Remain. I can see her position having to soften on Europe.

But a further Referendum? Not for a while.
 
If by getting things done you mean talking a load of incorrect statistics about Brexit, you might be right.

Starmer did most of this 'Brexit reset' anyway and when you look at the effect of it it's not clear whether these changes will benefit us slightly or worsen us slightly.

Burnham talks down Brexit, yet the British economy has been doing better than Germany's or France's over the last few years.....which isn't saying much due to the cost of living, but it's true.
Germany's economy has been linked to cheap fuel from the East that has caused them to sink in recent years.

France have better productivity that us, but suffer from an unsustainably higher debt and economic inflexibility relative to ours.

Being in the EU would not have tethered our economy to their relative declines. Instead, membership would have continued to provide free movement of the economic materials that may well have meant greater wealth than we have enjoyed.

Further - and you may enjoy this - our continued membership and free trade with our nearest neighbours may well have mutually improved their economies as well as ours. I am sure their relative decline is, at least partly, blamed on Brexit. In fact, how can it not be?
 
Germany's economy has been linked to cheap fuel from the East that has caused them to sink in recent years.

France have better productivity that us, but suffer from an unsustainably higher debt and economic inflexibility relative to ours.

Being in the EU would not have tethered our economy to their relative declines. Instead, membership would have continued to provide free movement of the economic materials that may well have meant greater wealth than we have enjoyed.

Further - and you may enjoy this - our continued membership and free trade with our nearest neighbours may well have mutually improved their economies as well as ours. I am sure their relative decline is, at least partly, blamed on Brexit. In fact, how can it not be?

The EU decided to play hardball with us economically so any part in their decline also relates to their own choices.

Neil goes over our economic position since Brexit and it paints a rather rosey picture than our pro EU government and indeed....remainers in general like to paint.

Personally I'm of the view that it didn't make very much of a difference at all, better in some ways and not in others.....with the added benefit of being able to decide our own laws....as any independent nation should automatically be able to.

The EU is a pension scheme and gravy train for middle managers to want to avoid all responsibility while picking up the largest cheque.
 
The statistical issue. Every man jack of the older male population votes. Meanwhile, there is a lower propensity for "Remain" voters to turn up. Hence, the current 55/33 split is likely to translate as an apparently closer vote. In 2016, the 52/48 split was wholly misleading on what "the people" wanted, but it was an accurate snap shot of what those who voted wanted.

Any future referendum on rejoining, much as the one on leaving, has to come on the back of a manifesto promise given by party who win a clear majority in the subsequent GE.

Which is clearly the conundrum for Labour.

Because whilst almost all the focus on 2016 is the 52/48 split in the actual Brexit vote, the breakdown that matters politically is that once the vote is weighted on a constituency basis, the the Leave majority is actually 60/40. And in terms of just England and Wales, then 70/30.

Hence why any decision to adopt it as a formal policy, is riven with potential electoral downsides.

I did think Burnham might actually have gone for a quick election given the boost in the polls Labour got when he took over, with this pro/return to the EU at the heart of it by way of hoovering up potential Greens and Lib Dems. but he bottled it. Or rather could not sell it to the rest of the party bigwigs.

Now I suspect they will look to just align us more and more closely with the EU until we might as well be back in it anyway. And the Tories, who let us not forget officially supported Remain as the party who called the Brexit vote, will not make too much fuss.
 
nothing to do with that. Blame politicians for that incompetence. Nope,by 'the good work' i mean following an anti EU electoral mandate.

Nobody voted for this latest stunt, by Burnham. Nor voted for him very much neither.

There wasn’t an anti EU mandate! That is the ridiculous self opinion of the die hard eurosceptic. Mandates are only possible at general elections in our representative democracy and are restricted solely to giving MPs the duty to make decisions on our behalf. Referendums have no role whatsoever in our system and can only be advisory. All the bleating by Farage is nonsense and those being fooled by him are as delusional.
 
There wasn’t an anti EU mandate! That is the ridiculous self opinion of the die hard eurosceptic. Mandates are only possible at general elections in our representative democracy and are restricted solely to giving MPs the duty to make decisions on our behalf. Referendums have no role whatsoever in our system and can only be advisory. All the bleating by Farage is nonsense and those being fooled by him are as delusional.
Wisbech surely you appreciate that in reality you can't hold a referendum and then not abide by the result, regardless of its legal standing ? That would be a recipe for insurrection.
 
Germany's economy has been linked to cheap fuel from the East that has caused them to sink in recent years.

France have better productivity that us, but suffer from an unsustainably higher debt and economic inflexibility relative to ours.

Being in the EU would not have tethered our economy to their relative declines. Instead, membership would have continued to provide free movement of the economic materials that may well have meant greater wealth than we have enjoyed.

Further - and you may enjoy this - our continued membership and free trade with our nearest neighbours may well have mutually improved their economies as well as ours. I am sure their relative decline is, at least partly, blamed on Brexit. In fact, how can it not be?
How can France be more productive on smaller GDP and similar population, the source can't be correct.
 
There wasn’t an anti EU mandate! That is the ridiculous self opinion of the die hard eurosceptic. Mandates are only possible at general elections in our representative democracy and are restricted solely to giving MPs the duty to make decisions on our behalf. Referendums have no role whatsoever in our system and can only be advisory. All the bleating by Farage is nonsense and those being fooled by him are as delusional.
What part of Labours mandate stated they would do a reset? What mandate does Burnham have to do this?
 
i predict an angry crowd marching in the streets.

Leave means Leave.


I don't think this is what people are angry about to march at anymore, they just get angry on the golf course.

Don't know why they are angry anyway. When we left it was about making our own deals but now Burnham is making one they are pissing their pants. Was the intention then to leave and not have any deals with anyone else ever?
 
Wisbech surely you appreciate that in reality you can't hold a referendum and then not abide by the result, regardless of its legal standing ? That would be a recipe for insurrection.

The mandate was to leave, and we left. Burnham has not rejoined so unless that happens there is no insurrection that you describe.
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top