WW2

I recently read a book about the Weimar republic years. What surprised me was that prior to Hitler becoming Chancellor and then Dictator his predecessors were no better in terms of democratic ruling. Hitler did not take over a democratic Germany as we would know it, the chancellors before him ruled with the backing of the army and abused their positions. Hitler just took it one step further.
 
prior to Hitler becoming Chancellor and then Dictator his predecessors were no better in terms of democratic ruling.
too much democracy is a bad thing. It all turns into a talking-shop where nothing ever gets done, nothing gets achieved. Its like a double decker bus with twenty or thirty steering-wheels.

Italy, Rep of Ireland, Weimar Germany.
 
you are correct Sterling. Had Hitler settled for taking Poland as his Leibensraun....living space, he would have been successful. It was utter madness to follow Napoleon's disastrous campaign East.

The only real purpose for taking Poland was geographical for the pathway to the Soviets.

Hitler was emboldened by his military successes and kept swinging for the fences, much as Trump did with Iran.
 
I suppose it's time for another look back.

Got the idea after seeing this Watson video.


If those that died could only have seen what was done with their sacrifice.

Betrayed by traitors.

Genuinely heartbreaking, imagine watching your friends get torn apart in the most horrific of ways only for your country to just turn into the thing you went to war to fight against. Only this time it was perpetrated by the government that sent you and your friends off to die. Depressing.
 
Genuinely heartbreaking, imagine watching your friends get torn apart in the most horrific of ways only for your country to just turn into the thing you went to war to fight against. Only this time it was perpetrated by the government that sent you and your friends off to die. Depressing.

100 percent.

Utter betrayal, the people who rule now aren't worth the dirt off of their shoes.
 
Genuinely heartbreaking, imagine watching your friends get torn apart in the most horrific of ways only for your country to just turn into the thing you went to war to fight against. Only this time it was perpetrated by the government that sent you and your friends off to die. Depressing.
Seems inappropriate to "like" this post, but you're spot on here. Lest we forget.
 
The only real purpose for taking Poland was geographical for the pathway to the Soviets.

Hitler was emboldened by his military successes and kept swinging for the fences, much as Trump did with Iran.

Having the pathway was important, but there were two other aspects to why Germany wanted Poland, they wanted to access to East Prussia (which is now basically Kaliningrad) and the Nazis considered Poles to be Slavic, so killing them is just as fine as killing Soviets.

Drastically different level of goals involved between trying take over all of the Soviet Union vs what Trump was/is trying to do in Iran.

Hitler's only hope of taking the Soviet Union was getting the people to uprise. Once the German's showed that they were actually worse than Stalin, he ensured that the Soviets would do a fighting retreat across thousands of miles that the German's would have no way of logistically sustaining.

Trump objectives in Iran.
  • Prevent Iranian Nuclear Weapons development
    • The most opaque of the four stated objectives. Trump can say that this was "achieved" while people who disagree could easily point out that that the previous strikes did the work. In reality, Nuclear Weapons development can be delayed, it cannot be permanently prevented without ground forces controlling the entire country.
  • Destroy Ballistic Missiles and missile industrial capacity
    • Achieved. The tactical task of destroy means that the target has to be reconstituted.
  • Annihilate the Iranian/IRGC Navy
    • Achieved. The task of annihilate doesn't mean destroy everything, it means that the Iranian/IRGC naval forces are not capable of sustained offensive operations and require complete constitution.
      • Nuance note: The difference between destroy and annihilation is that Iran can reconstitute some of its missile capacity while in contact. It won't be able to rebuild its navy until everything is over.
  • Sever Iranian Proxy Support throughout the Middle East
    • Achieved. Iranian support for its proxies throughout the Middle East continues to shrink. Some of those proxies are able to be self sustaining, but they are doing without extensive Iranian support.

The issue for Trump/US is that killing off the Ayatollah has left a power vacuum in Iran where there isn't anyone who can force the IRGC to stop for the betterment of Iran. So instead, the rest of the world starts to find workarounds for how to get resources out of the Middle East with the constraint that Iran will attack ships if it has the opportunity. Iran on the other hand doesn't have much options but since the pecking order is that the IRGC gets taken care of first, it will be the normal Iranian's who continue to suffer more and more as it goes on.

It is a Doom Loop between two sides who want to be stubborn, and now have no reason to change anything for at least the next two years. So that should be fun.
 
there should also be a remembrance event for dodgy governments who betray the people.
The upgrades to the American VA system in the last 25 years are absolutely incredible. It has gone from being one in which veterans went to die and now the quality of care is absolutely top notch.

Some American Vets still slip the through cracks, but when you see how other nations ften treat their veterans it is absolutely shocking.

And if you ever see how Russian vets are treated, you'd want to vomit. It looks like something out of the Crimean War/US Civil War with both their field medicine and their after care/government support.
 
Here is a Black Mirror storyline. Get a time machine and beam yourself back to the VE day celebrations in the streets. Erect giant flatscreen TV's and show the crowds what the UK is in 2026.

1794868212221.webp
 

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top