What the hell is happening at our club ?

Well exactly, its the only model.

The best players at every club (potentially bar Madrid and Barca) are up for moving on and up. Its always been part of the game and and always will be.

If you decide that you are going to refuse to sell your best players, they will leave for free, and it will impact your ability to attract talent moving forward.
Release clauses are mandatory in Spanish football but Real Madrid and Barcelona get around them by setting the price at €1 bn for their stars which makes it seem a bit pointless for all but the biggest clubs. Maybe that's the point.
 
I mentioned this the other day, it's not a great business model. The problem is I don't see an alternative. Clubs like Moan United can always buy their way out of trouble, an option not available to the like of Palace.

Regarding the delay in announcing I have two further suggestions as why Parish maybe innocent.

1. The assumption is that the delay was the club, we don' know that. Maybe it was Sage who needed a couple of days to go over the release deal with his lawyers and Parish did the decent thing and gave him the time?

2. Whatever deal was agreed I would assume the shareholders would have had some input. So again the deal may have been done but Parish was waiting for one of the American owners to rubber stamp it.

Anyway it's done now.
I think you can sell your best players if you are smart in the transfer market. Example - selling Andersen for £30m and signing Lacroix for £17m.

But our recruitment generally has been poor for a while now.

I agree with you, we have little choice in the matter.
 
I think you can sell your best players if you are smart in the transfer market. Example - selling Andersen for £30m and signing Lacroix for £17m.

But our recruitment generally has been poor for a while now.

I agree with you, we have little choice in the matter.
Yeah, you can but that is a very difficult game to play and ultimately the teams that we ‘beat’ in that situation are Fulham and Wolfsburg. If we do well over them we can climb above average teams in Europe and mid-lower Premier League teams, as we have but even then we are not the ultimate winner of that story.

Ultimately Chelsea are, as the bigger clubs generally are, getting LeCroix at his peak, whilst getting us to give PL experience to a young centre back and cutting Disase from their wage bill whilst retaining the right to recall him in n injury crisis/if he does well for us. It costs them but they have the money.

Every transfer in and out is a gamble and after a period of Freedman being largely successful our recent gambles have not paid off. Hobbs’ track record is not good and he needs to go.
 
Yeah, you can but that is a very difficult game to play and ultimately the teams that we ‘beat’ in that situation are Fulham and Wolfsburg. If we do well over them we can climb above average teams in Europe and mid-lower Premier League teams, as we have but even then we are not the ultimate winner of that story.

Ultimately Chelsea are, as the bigger clubs generally are, getting LeCroix at his peak, whilst getting us to give PL experience to a young centre back and cutting Disase from their wage bill whilst retaining the right to recall him in n injury crisis/if he does well for us. It costs them but they have the money.

Every transfer in and out is a gamble and after a period of Freedman being largely successful our recent gambles have not paid off. Hobbs’ track record is not good and he needs to go.
A player who's not performing can be dropped but with a...whatever his job title is... there aren't many options other than a soldier's farewell.
 
Yeah, you can but that is a very difficult game to play and ultimately the teams that we ‘beat’ in that situation are Fulham and Wolfsburg. If we do well over them we can climb above average teams in Europe and mid-lower Premier League teams, as we have but even then we are not the ultimate winner of that story.

Ultimately Chelsea are, as the bigger clubs generally are, getting LeCroix at his peak, whilst getting us to give PL experience to a young centre back and cutting Disase from their wage bill whilst retaining the right to recall him in n injury crisis/if he does well for us. It costs them but they have the money.

Every transfer in and out is a gamble and after a period of Freedman being largely successful our recent gambles have not paid off. Hobbs’ track record is not good and he needs to go.
This is right. It is a bit self fulfilling but selling your best players and trying to replace them works right up until it doesn’t. Like Brighton now, Southampton were viewed as the model of recruitment until suddenly it stopped working. It doesn’t mean the recruitment teams are idiots just that the gambles don’t pay off in a window.

Interestingly in the latest Ed Aarons piece he hints that Freedman is still consulted on transfers. If true that seems very off and no wonder our recruitment looks confused if two people have a hand in it. As ever we don’t know the truth but it probably isn’t quite as simple as Hobbs being a fool and Dougie being a genius.
 
Yeah, you can but that is a very difficult game to play and ultimately the teams that we ‘beat’ in that situation are Fulham and Wolfsburg. If we do well over them we can climb above average teams in Europe and mid-lower Premier League teams, as we have but even then we are not the ultimate winner of that story.

Ultimately Chelsea are, as the bigger clubs generally are, getting LeCroix at his peak, whilst getting us to give PL experience to a young centre back and cutting Disase from their wage bill whilst retaining the right to recall him in n injury crisis/if he does well for us. It costs them but they have the money.

Every transfer in and out is a gamble and after a period of Freedman being largely successful our recent gambles have not paid off. Hobbs’ track record is not good and he needs to go.

No but we never will be.

Sad as it sounds, we're only trying not to be the loser.
 
Sky's Paper Talk summed us up with "you can't keep,selling your best players and hope to replace them". No kidding? What incisive commentary that was but what they didn't mention was that if players won't sign without a release there's not a lot we can do about it.
And if we don't sell them then a) they won't come here and if they do then b) they'll all leave on a free. Which is obviously much worse.
 
Release clauses are mandatory in Spanish football but Real Madrid and Barcelona get around them by setting the price at €1 bn for their stars which makes it seem a bit pointless for all but the biggest clubs. Maybe that's the point.
Release clause will become the norm in football and rightly so. When you sign a work contract it spells out how you leave e.g. 3 months notice.

Without a release clause you are asking a player / worker to sign a contract without knowing how they can exit it. That is simply not fair.

The release clause is up to individual negotiation. Personally I would not sign a contract with a 1bn release clause because it's pointless. I also would not agree to the other side being able to extend the contract without my consent, but that's me.
 
One of the reasons why people are so disillusioned with the Premier League is the sheer imbalace of the competition.

It means a player like Eze, who would be one of the first names on the teamsheet at Palace, is one of the last names on the teamsheets at Arsenal.

The big clubs have ridiculously bloated squads with rarely featuring players who would be guaranteed starters at Palace.

It leads to situations, as someone alluded to earlier, where Chelsea can take our best centre back in Lacroix and leave us with one of theirs who they have been trying to offload for a couple of seasons (Disasi) and a youngster they are looking for us to develop on their behalf (Ahanor).

It leads to Liverpool feeling entitled to try and pinch Sarr for £40 million while selling Gakpo at twice the price.

I don't have a solution and if anything feel it will get rather worse.
 
One of the reasons why people are so disillusioned with the Premier League is the sheer imbalace of the competition.

It means a player like Eze, who would be one of the first names on the teamsheet at Palace, is one of the last names on the teamsheets at Arsenal.

The big clubs have ridiculously bloated squads with rarely featuring players who would be guaranteed starters at Palace.

It leads to situations, as someone alluded to earlier, where Chelsea can take our best centre back in Lacroix and leave us with one of theirs who they have been trying to offload for a couple of seasons (Disasi) and a youngster they are looking for us to develop on their behalf (Ahanor).

It leads to Liverpool feeling entitled to try and pinch Sarr for £40 million while selling Gakpo at twice the price.

I don't have a solution and if anything feel it will get rather worse.
Fear you're right. And even with all the advantages they had Man City still felt the need to cheat their way around the rules.
 
Yeah, you can but that is a very difficult game to play and ultimately the teams that we ‘beat’ in that situation are Fulham and Wolfsburg. If we do well over them we can climb above average teams in Europe and mid-lower Premier League teams, as we have but even then we are not the ultimate winner of that story.

Ultimately Chelsea are, as the bigger clubs generally are, getting LeCroix at his peak, whilst getting us to give PL experience to a young centre back and cutting Disase from their wage bill whilst retaining the right to recall him in n injury crisis/if he does well for us. It costs them but they have the money.

Every transfer in and out is a gamble and after a period of Freedman being largely successful our recent gambles have not paid off. Hobbs’ track record is not good and he needs to go.
Our model has been centred around signing players, developing them and then cashing in on them - for two reasons - we need the money and we are not a “ destination club “ as Steve Parish puts it.

And that was working to an extent . But, Wharton aside, and maybe Henderson and Sarr to a degree , who else is there in our present squad ?

Strand Larsen we would be lucky to get our money back on ( how Chelsea turned a profit on the similar Delap , I’ll never know ! ), and we certainly copped a hit with Johnson.

Freedman was a tough act to follow. But I fail to see how the Palace hierarchy can look at Hobbs and conclude he’s doing even an average job.
 
Our model has been centred around signing players, developing them and then cashing in on them - for two reasons - we need the money and we are not a “ destination club “ as Steve Parish puts it.

And that was working to an extent . But, Wharton aside, and maybe Henderson and Sarr to a degree , who else is there in our present squad ?

Strand Larsen we would be lucky to get our money back on ( how Chelsea turned a profit on the similar Delap , I’ll never know ! ), and we certainly copped a hit with Johnson.

Freedman was a tough act to follow. But I fail to see how the Palace hierarchy can look at Hobbs and conclude he’s doing even an average job.
At the end of last season I think most people would have been fairly confident in Canvot becoming another £40m/50m defender over the coming years.

The next biggest resale value probably comes from Osorio, Pino and (to a lesser extent) Gozo. I think the club are probably hoping that one of those goes on to become a more valuable player, one might be a longer term players for us, and the last one is someone we might just recoup money on. Certainly given their ages you’d hope you wouldn’t be losing significant amounts on them.

Khalaili again, based in age, has almost certainly been signed with that principle in mind as well.
 
At the end of last season I think most people would have been fairly confident in Canvot becoming another £40m/50m defender over the coming years.

The next biggest resale value probably comes from Osorio, Pino and (to a lesser extent) Gozo. I think the club are probably hoping that one of those goes on to become a more valuable player, one might be a longer term players for us, and the last one is someone we might just recoup money on. Certainly given their ages you’d hope you wouldn’t be losing significant amounts on them.

Khalaili again, based in age, has almost certainly been signed with that principle in mind as well.
I think you’re right of course in mentioning those players . I was looking at the current situation as opposed to the future.

Canvot hasn’t developed as well as I’d hoped but I think that’s partly down to the general instability in our defence this season.

The others…..Pino we could turn a profit on while he’s being selected for Spain . The rest are ‘ work in progress ‘ , let’s see !
 
Given all the comments above there are 2 obvious requirements going forward:

1. A manager who can bring the best out of the young talent we have. Hopefully Thomas Frank is that man and we will see a stable back 4 with Mingueza and Mitchell either side of Richards and Canvot so the latter can flourish. Also Osorio and the young American lad who is so far out of things that I can’t
even remember his name!

2. A DoF who returns to the policy that worked for us under Dougie by scouting young talent ready for the team rather than paying over the odds for players who have not lived up to their huge price tags elsewhere. I’m not convinced Hobbs is that man. For our club it’s possibly the most important role next to Parish. If as some here say Parish is on a salary of millions he should fly to Saudi and offer what it takes to bring Dougie back.
 
At the end of last season I think most people would have been fairly confident in Canvot becoming another £40m/50m defender over the coming years.

The next biggest resale value probably comes from Osorio, Pino and (to a lesser extent) Gozo. I think the club are probably hoping that one of those goes on to become a more valuable player, one might be a longer term players for us, and the last one is someone we might just recoup money on. Certainly given their ages you’d hope you wouldn’t be losing significant amounts on them.

Khalaili again, based in age, has almost certainly been signed with that principle in mind as well.
I largely agree with this, but think these signings show us a few interesting things.

1. Eze, Guehi, Wharton, and Olise mostly had some good-level first team football under their belts when we bought them. They were stepping up to the EPL, but were not total novices. They had played a decent number of competitive games in England. They got better over time, but were largely just about good enough from the outset. A lot of those things are not true of Canvot, Osorio, Pino, Khalili, and certainly Gozo, just like they weren't true of Franca or even Esse. By definition a 'potential development' player is unproven, but there are degrees of risk, and we went for longer and longer shots over time: Players who had played far less football and/or at lower levels and/or outside of England. I don't know if that was us trying to be clever, or that there were less prospects in the championship, or value became harder to find, but it is very different.

2. Eze et al came into a settled squad with a core of solid senior players who were not going anywhere, and so would work hard to ensure Palace stayed in the league. I imagine that creates a culture. The new batch came in to a group in flux, where the better players felt they had achieved all they could with Palace and wanted to move onwards and upwards, possibly fairly so as they, unlike Dann, Ward, MacArthur etc, had all signed for a feeder club. The type of core to which young hopefuls are added makes a huge difference. We don't have to guess how much help a Dann or a Cahill would give to a Canvot - we have seen how much better he was with Lacroix.

3. If you add up the profits on the Olise, Guehi, Eze and (one day) Wharton batch, it will more than cover the flops like Franca. Now, we need at least two of Canvot, Osorio, Pino, Khalili, or Gozo to go for megabucks just to break even on the rest of them. The first batch gave us profits to reinvest or cover losses. The second batch seem unlikely to.

To me, the whole buy, develop, sell, begin again model is no more than OK at best. Overall it comes with as many inbuilt flaws as trying to get by on journeymen. We couldn't have hit gold more solidly than we did with the Eze batch, and it still hasn't changed our world. We are not really much better off than we were with the journeymen. League place is much the same, and we were minutes away from winning the FA cup in 2016, so not as if even that success can be put down to the new model.
 
Last edited:

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top