Actors whose real identity was 'out of whack' with the onscreen-character

Location
Area 51
Country
USA
AGE
Marlon Brando was only 48 when he played the elderly Don Corleone.

in 'The Graduate' Dustin Hoffman is being seduced and chased by the much older woman 'Mrs Robinson'. In reality the two actors were only 6 years apart in age.

the karate kid was 17, portrayed by a 23 year old actor. Very often Hollywood had teens played by people much older. Although the trend seems to be less prevalent now.

Gladiator. Richard Harris, 70, played Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius... who had died by age 58.

IDENTITY

HBO ROME....Ciaran Hinds (irish) as Caesar and Giovanni Calcagno (italian) as Leader of the Gauls, Vercingetorix. So we have a Celt (from beyond the Empire) playing a Roman and a True Roman playing a Barbarian Celt.

The Fonz in 'Happy Days'. Italian ? yeah roight.

Timothy Chalamet in 'The King'.....sounds like a posh englishman. And he also did a good impression of an aristocrat speaking Norman French.

Anthony Hopkins as President Nixon. If we had a quid for every time a Brit played a Yank.....we would be a dollar millionaire. Cross the Atlantic.

Keanu Reeves as Jonathan Harper in Dracula......Yanks often are incapable of returning the compliment across the Pond.

Steptoe.....Wilfred Bramble playing a Straight-Cockney Father. He was neither and often fluffed the accent. Bramble got divorced when the wife got impregnated by their lodger. Back in the day, gays were often pressured into getting married by older family members. As per Oscar Wilde.....an irishman badly portrayed by Stephen Fry who didnt even bother to try the accent.

Brad Pitt in Snatch. Apart from a brilliant accent, There is absolutely no way you can be a gypsy bare-knuckle boxing champion AND ALSO be that good-looking.

what others ?



 
Last edited:
Richard Vernon was 39 when he played the stuffy old bloke on the train in A Hard Day's Night.
Christopher Lloyd was 46 in Back to the Future.
Sean Connery - 12 years older than his son Indiana Jones.
Lorne Greene in Bonanza - 13 years older than his son Hoss.
Angela Lansbury was 3 years older than her son Laurence Harvey in The Manchurian Candidate.
Stockard Channing was 33 in Grease.
 
Lionel Jeffries was only 42 when he played the Grandpa in Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. He always looked older but was quite young when his peak acting was the 1950's.

Sally Field played Tom Hanks love interest in Punchline 6 years later she played his mum in Forest Gump. Ouch that must have hurt.
 
Lionel Jeffries was only 42 when he played the Grandpa in Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. He always looked older but was quite young when his peak acting was the 1950's.

Sally Field played Tom Hanks love interest in Punchline 6 years later she played his mum in Forest Gump. Ouch that must have hurt.
Indeed but not as much as Eileen Herlie in Hamlet (1948) where she played Laurence Olivier's mother despite being 11 years younger than him.
 
When steptoe and son started in 1962 wilfried bramble played the father in his 60's even though he was only 49. Harry h corbett who played his son was only 36.
 
Clive Dunn was famously not that old in Dad's Army.

And I seem to recall the cherubic Richard Attenborough played a 13 year old school boy aged about 26
 
Munoz or maybe even Julian Speroni could have done a more convincing mexican than the fella in the link below. Maybe it was difficult to find a convincing mexican actor in the vicinity of Los Angeles ?

 
Last edited:
Here is an old Witch. The actress was 4 years younger than Scarlett Johansson is today.


..........................................................................

Eddie Redmayne did a convincing portrayal of Stephen Hawking. Wheelchair and all. Franklin D. Roosevelt did a convincing portrayal of an able bodied US President - aided and abetted by the various media outlets.

T-total Ewan McGregor in the re-make of The Shining. He plays Danny Torrence, a druggy alcoholic. Again, probably too good looking to play a lifelong p1.sshead.

John Wayne played the all american cowboy hero - WASPY characters. In real life he married 3 Latina women and spent most of his time speaking Spanish at home.
Photogenic Hollywood heart-throbs Clark Gable and James Dean.......both had dentures. Again we have massive numbers of other stars pretending to have a gap or otherwise bad teeth.

Some critics decried the casting of Italian-american Robert De Niro in 'The Irishman'. Fake blue contact-lens and platform shoes to become Mr Sheeran. In spite of the fact that the real Sheeran was less irish than De Niro ( 3 grandparents).

OPPOSITES TO THE THREAD
you may also pepper the thread with actors who were surprisingly close to the part they played on screen.
The Sopranos, Paulie Walnuts....the actor had been in the real mafia.

 
Last edited:
Here is an old Witch. The actress was 4 years younger than Scarlett Johansson is today.


..........................................................................

Eddie Redmayne did a convincing portrayal of Stephen Hawking. Wheelchair and all. Franklin D. Roosevelt did a convincing portrayal of an able bodied US President - aided and abetted by the various media outlets.

T-total Ewan McGregor in the re-make of The Shining. He plays Danny Torrence, a druggy alcoholic. Again, probably too good looking to play a lifelong p1.sshead.

OPPOSITES TO THE THREAD
you may also pepper the thread with actors who were surprisingly close to the part they played on screen.
The Sopranos, Paulie Walnuts....the actor had been in the real mafia.
Tony Sirico, the actor that played Pauline Walnuts was an actor for quite a long time in gangster films and woody Allen films. Was he in the mafia when he was much younger and then turned his life around (like Danny Trejo)?
 
Here is an old Witch. The actress was 4 years younger than Scarlett Johansson is today.


..........................................................................

Eddie Redmayne did a convincing portrayal of Stephen Hawking. Wheelchair and all. Franklin D. Roosevelt did a convincing portrayal of an able bodied US President - aided and abetted by the various media outlets.

T-total Ewan McGregor in the re-make of The Shining. He plays Danny Torrence, a druggy alcoholic. Again, probably too good looking to play a lifelong p1.sshead.

John Wayne played the all american cowboy hero - WASPY characters. In real life he married 3 Latina women and spent most of his time speaking Spanish at home.
Photogenic Hollywood heart-throbs Clark Gable and James Dean.......both had dentures. Again we have massive numbers of other stars pretending to have a gap or otherwise bad teeth.

Some critics decried the casting of Italian-american Robert De Niro in 'The Irishman'. Fake blue contact-lens and platform shoes to become Mr Sheeran. In spite of the fact that the real Sheeran was less irish than De Niro ( 3 grandparents).

OPPOSITES TO THE THREAD
you may also pepper the thread with actors who were surprisingly close to the part they played on screen.
The Sopranos, Paulie Walnuts....the actor had been in the real mafia.

I seem to recall a picture of the actor who played Leotardo surrounded by wise guys.
 
‘Please Sir’ that classic old comedy from the early 70’s, all the ‘kids’ were in their mid 20’s in real life

Someone mentioned Reg Varney in on the buses, he was only 6 years younger than his mum Doris Hare
Good one.
Peter Cleall (Eric Duffy) is 81 which is an odd thought when you remember him being at school.
 
cmon Eagles. You also score marks when the on-screen actor closely MATCHES them off screen.

The shouty bloke below was the real deal. A proper Drill sargeant. Not just an actor.

 
Last edited:
Tough guy, hard man on the street. Becomes tough guy on the telly.

- jean claude Van Damm...a genuine karate champion.
- Stephen Seagull....fake tough guy, black belt in Obesity-jitsu.
- Jason Statham....black belt
- Keanu Reeves....jiu jitsu
- Vinney Jones..... defo he was a violent thug
- Chuck Norris.... won many fighting titles & prizes
- Bruce Lee.....despised by stunt-men whom he often deliberately injured. Never won a real fight in his life. A glorified ballet dancer. 55 kilos and always sick. He seemed to engender more spats, feuds and beefs than a Brighton hairdresser.
etc etc

Robert De Niro needed to become the boxer to play Jake LaMotta. So they sent him for some lessons. Eventually he became quite good.

Karate Kid....Pat Morita.....couldn't beat his way out of a wet Rice-paper bag. Hilarious really. There are actually many on-screen tough guys who couldn't take on our sponge-Eagle mascot man even if he had his wings tied behind his back. Clint Eastwood ?
Orlando Bloom.....dozens of sword swashbuckling adventures. I guess it unlikely for a fella to be a Joey Barton if he has also worked as a male model - as did Orlando.

Kung Fu David Carradine ? he had a black belt. Not in Karate, but a black belt in being related to other Hollywood royalty.

Oliver Reed.....not a hard-man as per the martial artists mentioned above. But likely to get into a drunken brawl and be unable to remember it afterwards.
 
Tough guy, hard man on the street. Becomes tough guy on the telly.

- jean claude Van Damm...a genuine karate champion.
- Stephen Seagull....fake tough guy, black belt in Obesity-jitsu.
- Jason Statham....black belt
- Keanu Reeves....jiu jitsu
- Vinney Jones..... defo he was a violent thug
- Chuck Norris.... won many fighting titles & prizes
- Bruce Lee.....despised by stunt-men whom he often deliberately injured. Never won a real fight in his life. A glorified ballet dancer. 55 kilos and always sick. He seemed to engender more spats, feuds and beefs than a Brighton hairdresser.
etc etc

Robert De Niro needed to become the boxer to play Jake LaMotta. So they sent him for some lessons. Eventually he became quite good.

Karate Kid....Pat Morita.....couldn't beat his way out of a wet Rice-paper bag. Hilarious really. There are actually many on-screen tough guys who couldn't take on our sponge-Eagle mascot man even if he had his wings tied behind his back. Clint Eastwood ?
Orlando Bloom.....dozens of sword swashbuckling adventures. I guess it unlikely for a fella to be a Joey Barton if he has also worked as a male model - as did Orlando.

Kung Fu David Carradine ? he had a black belt. Not in Karate, but a black belt in being related to other Hollywood royalty.

Oliver Reed.....not a hard-man as per the martial artists mentioned above. But likely to get into a drunken brawl and be unable to remember it afterwards.
Dolph Lundgren? Twice European karate champion.
 
Dolph Lundgren? Twice European karate champion.

that's a good call Eagle. Dolph was identical on and off screen.

Looking to cast an actor to play a retired Champion Gladiator ? You could get a tired clapped-out alcoholic, from Wimbledon. A bloke with only a few hours life left in the poor feckers lungs. Who really couldn't beat an egg.


Or you could recruit the retired hardest b@..stard on the planet. I wonder why the latter is used so infrequently ?


When you remember Diego Maradona, you remember that even the best get old and tired.
 
Last edited:

Holmesdale Online Shop

Back
Top