Teddy Eagle
Member
- Country
Scotland
Yes, Marco Pierre Whitehorse Lane.Did we get a new chef yet?
Scotland
Yes, Marco Pierre Whitehorse Lane.Did we get a new chef yet?
I heard Frank is keen to bring Tomori in from Milan. Only has 6 months left on his contract and though he is discussing a new deal he is open to returning to England. Milan would accept a modest transfer fee rather than lose him for nothing in the summer.Despite their attributes Pino and Kamada aren't great defensively add in Khalaili and we're soft through the middle. Wharton isn't the best tackler but we should be able to compensate for him - having four players to cover is never going to work
Frank is apparently a fan of Gallaghers if we could get/afford him that would be a start but as everyone knows we still need more strength in central defence. Send Disasi back and replace him with...somebody, preferably not another Chelsea reject.
England
To be honest, anyone other than what we’ve got at the moment is just what we need 🤣I heard Frank is keen to bring Tomori in from Milan. Only has 6 months left on his contract and though he is discussing a new deal he is open to returning to England. Milan would accept a modest transfer fee rather than lose him for nothing in the summer.
I think with a bith of Frank love he could be just what we need.
Scotland
He's an interesting option. Got experience and got into the England team earlier in his career. He doesn't seem to have really settled anywhere but maybe he can with Palace.I heard Frank is keen to bring Tomori in from Milan. Only has 6 months left on his contract and though he is discussing a new deal he is open to returning to England. Milan would accept a modest transfer fee rather than lose him for nothing in the summer.
I think with a bith of Frank love he could be just what we need.
Scotland
Like the Woody Allen line that the only regret in his life is that he isn't someone else.To be honest, anyone other than what we’ve got at the moment is just what we need 🤣
England
TOtally agreeBut whatever happens, the sound was always driven by the Ultras. Without their presence we will simply not get that atmosphere which is sorely missing at the ground. We desperately need them back. Selhurst is just not Selhurst without them.
Scotland
Get Steve to say it was all Sage's fault.But whatever happens, the sound was always driven by the Ultras. Without their presence we will simply not get that atmosphere which is sorely missing at the ground. We desperately need them back. Selhurst is just not Selhurst without them.
Australia
But whatever happens, the sound was always driven by the Ultras. Without their presence we will simply not get that atmosphere which is sorely missing at the ground. We desperately need them back. Selhurst is just not Selhurst without them.
England
Great attitude, I know people that went to school with him, he was a leader at every level: it’s a bit of a rugby school but they love him there. If we get a good deal he could be an ideal signing to add depth to defence with something to proveI heard Frank is keen to bring Tomori in from Milan. Only has 6 months left on his contract and though he is discussing a new deal he is open to returning to England. Milan would accept a modest transfer fee rather than lose him for nothing in the summer.
I think with a bith of Frank love he could be just what we need.
Scotland
He may and attacking crosses will suit McNeil and JSL. Crosses into our area won't suit anybody - Richards will be a busy fellow.There's an interesting breakdown of the formations and tactics that Frank has used in the past on the Palace website.
The split between a back 5 and back 4 is roughly 50/50.
When playing a top 6 club a back 5 has been the usual option.
Defensively the tendency has been to block the central passing lanes with spaces allowed out wide reasoning that the central defenders will deal with the resultant crosses.
This is reminiscent of Roy's approach, and it's noteworthy that Frank's Brentford team won the most aerial duels in the division.
Frank would use 2 up front ( e.g Toney and Mbueno) on occasions and attack wise there was a focus on getting crosses in.
If Frank wants to follow a similar approach to the above with us I would question whether we can do this entirely successfully with the players who have largely featured this season.
But we'll see.
He may bring things out in the players that were not evident under Sage.
England
That’ll be in January when SP tells him all we can afford is Ade Adedonkey from Tooting & MitchamHas he fallen out with Parish yet?
England
Whether or not the current squad are all capable of playing as you describe, it nevertheless all sounds exactly as I want any Palace manager to play.There's an interesting breakdown of the formations and tactics that Frank has used in the past on the Palace website.
The split between a back 5 and back 4 is roughly 50/50.
When playing a top 6 club a back 5 has been the usual option.
Defensively the tendency has been to block the central passing lanes with spaces allowed out wide reasoning that the central defenders will deal with the resultant crosses.
This is reminiscent of Roy's approach, and it's noteworthy that Frank's Brentford team won the most aerial duels in the division.
Frank would use 2 up front ( e.g Toney and Mbueno) on occasions and attack wise there was a focus on getting crosses in.
If Frank wants to follow a similar approach to the above with us I would question whether we can do this entirely successfully with the players who have largely featured this season.
But we'll see.
He may bring things out in the players that were not evident under Sage.
Wales
The transfer windows are when the disagreements start. Personally, I wouldn't give Thomas that long.That’ll be in January when SP tells him all we can afford is Ade Adedonkey from Tooting & Mitcham
England
I intend to start a protest against your protest. Like you, I am not sure what exactly I object to, but it probably has something to do with 'Them' and 'Us, the hardworking, loyal fans' and 'Passion' and being badly let down and stuff like that. Do you want to join me? It would probably be easier. At least then I can feel confident that my protest against your protest is taking place at the same time and place as your protest? 🙂The transfer windows are when the disagreements start. Personally, I wouldn't give Thomas that long.
If we Palace don't beat Coventry by at least 5 goals, then I'm going to organise a protest march from Norwood Clocktower to the ground for next Thursday when Palace play Real Sociedad.
Not too sure what the main thrust of the protest will be, but who's with me ? 😀
England
I'm with you all the way, brother......well, until we reach The Victory, then I'm out!!The transfer windows are when the disagreements start. Personally, I wouldn't give Thomas that long.
If Palace don't beat Coventry by at least 5 goals, then I'm going to organise a protest march from Norwood Clocktower to the ground for next Thursday when Palace play Real Sociedad.
Not too sure what the main thrust of the protest will be, but who's with me ? 😀
England
If you’re starting at the Norwood Clocktower, mind if I nip in and get my hair cut first?🤣 I think my old hair dressers is still thereThe transfer windows are when the disagreements start. Personally, I wouldn't give Thomas that long.
If Palace don't beat Coventry by at least 5 goals, then I'm going to organise a protest march from Norwood Clocktower to the ground for next Thursday when Palace play Real Sociedad.
Not too sure what the main thrust of the protest will be, but who's with me ? 😀
Agree with all of this. If he plays a back four it is Richards Disasi as centre backs and Mitchell and Mingueza as full backs. If he plays a back three it has to be Lerma. Canvot can’t be starting. He still has promise but he makes too many bad decisions. Until he cuts that out of his game he can’t be a regular starter.Whether or not the current squad are all capable of playing as you describe, it nevertheless all sounds exactly as I want any Palace manager to play.
I cannot imagine is us playing tippy-tappy possession based football through the thirds successfully under anybody, and I am glad it is seemingly not in Frank's wheelhouse. Whether we seek to pin teams in their own half through direct play or sit in our own half and hit on the break, the emphasis should be on effort, pace, and power in at least 9 of the 11 players, because that is far easier to find and replace than top-level technical quality. We can have a Wharton or maybe a Kamada for a bit of guile, but only if they get stuck in.
Up top, the key assets were always Mateta and Sarr, now all the more so. Of the also-rans I could perhaps see Pino as a third forward but his lack of physicality may well go against him. Its not just that he is almost comically small and stumpy, its that he doesn't have any pace. Difficult to imagine him being effective playing direct football or on the break, but he may continue his long-overdue and gradual improvement by getting good at picking up second balls and knock-downs around the box. It will not be like playing for Spain, and he will have to want to do it. Ideally, he would become the new Wimbledon-era Dennis Wise! It is equally likely that he just fades from view.
Larsen might be useful if he ever learns to punch his weight, but he hasn't so far. I could imagine McNeill being useful in getting the ball in the box more, and he has put a shift in when picked. Not exactly rapid, though, and a limited player overall. Osario maybe has a chance, even if only because nobody else has done enough, although that's not exactly a good basis upon which to select a player.
At the back we must treat Riad as finished and Tomiyasu and Chillwell as unexpected bonuses if they ever play. Khalili cannot be permitted to play right back under any circumstances, and should probably not be under consideration for the right wingback spot for some time. Mingueza is getting into a lot of peoples XI on the back of how bad Khalili is, rather than anything he has done himself. Perhaps one of them can play right-midfield (I would like to see Khalili taken out of the firing line for weeks, and then brought on as a sub in right mid to see if we can build him back up a bit).
In any event, the rightback spot is there for Mingueza to take if he can do it. He has looked awful defensively at times, but perhaps would do OK if given a run of games in a stable set up. The rest of the back four picks itself if Richards, Desasi, and Mitchell are fit. Those are not world-beating centre backs by any means, but Canvot has been shocking and needs to be far lower in the pecking order for his and our good. I am doubtful that we have anybody reliable to come in as the third centre back if Frank wants to go to a back five.
I can imagine a moment, perhaps next summer, when we have stayed up having signed a player or two in the Jan, have lost Mateta, and are looking at putting together next years squad when Frank says 'Steve, Matt, the simple truth is that a lot of these players you brought in before I got here are not good enough, and/or are wrong for my style of play. I have no use for some of them, including those you hoped to develop and sell for profit'.
I think perhaps only an experienced premier league manager can say that, whereas a foreign-based coach would be more used to working with what he is given and less inclined to play direct, no nonsense football. For all the talk that Frank simply benefited from the Brentford recruitment process, he does seem to have a type of player he likes (physical), and it would be interesting to see if it all ends up with Palace buying players of that type to suit the manager, rather than playing moneyball (as understandable as that approach is).
Whether or not the current squad are all capable of playing as you describe, it nevertheless all sounds exactly as I want any Palace manager to play.
I cannot imagine is us playing tippy-tappy possession based football through the thirds successfully under anybody, and I am glad it is seemingly not in Frank's wheelhouse. Whether we seek to pin teams in their own half through direct play or sit in our own half and hit on the break, the emphasis should be on effort, pace, and power in at least 9 of the 11 players, because that is far easier to find and replace than top-level technical quality. We can have a Wharton or maybe a Kamada for a bit of guile, but only if they get stuck in.
Up top, the key assets were always Mateta and Sarr, now all the more so. Of the also-rans I could perhaps see Pino as a third forward but his lack of physicality may well go against him. Its not just that he is almost comically small and stumpy, its that he doesn't have any pace. Difficult to imagine him being effective playing direct football or on the break, but he may continue his long-overdue and gradual improvement by getting good at picking up second balls and knock-downs around the box. It will not be like playing for Spain, and he will have to want to do it. Ideally, he would become the new Wimbledon-era Dennis Wise! It is equally likely that he just fades from view.
Larsen might be useful if he ever learns to punch his weight, but he hasn't so far. I could imagine McNeill being useful in getting the ball in the box more, and he has put a shift in when picked. Not exactly rapid, though, and a limited player overall. Osario maybe has a chance, even if only because nobody else has done enough, although that's not exactly a good basis upon which to select a player.
At the back we must treat Riad as finished and Tomiyasu and Chillwell as unexpected bonuses if they ever play. Khalili cannot be permitted to play right back under any circumstances, and should probably not be under consideration for the right wingback spot for some time. Mingueza is getting into a lot of peoples XI on the back of how bad Khalili is, rather than anything he has done himself. Perhaps one of them can play right-midfield (I would like to see Khalili taken out of the firing line for weeks, and then brought on as a sub in right mid to see if we can build him back up a bit).
In any event, the rightback spot is there for Mingueza to take if he can do it. He has looked awful defensively at times, but perhaps would do OK if given a run of games in a stable set up. The rest of the back four picks itself if Richards, Desasi, and Mitchell are fit. Those are not world-beating centre backs by any means, but Canvot has been shocking and needs to be far lower in the pecking order for his and our good. I am doubtful that we have anybody reliable to come in as the third centre back if Frank wants to go to a back five.
I can imagine a moment, perhaps next summer, when we have stayed up having signed a player or two in the Jan, have lost Mateta, and are looking at putting together next years squad when Frank says 'Steve, Matt, the simple truth is that a lot of these players you brought in before I got here are not good enough, and/or are wrong for my style of play. I have no use for some of them, including those you hoped to develop and sell for profit'.
I think perhaps only an experienced premier league manager can say that, whereas a foreign-based coach would be more used to working with what he is given and less inclined to play direct, no nonsense football. For all the talk that Frank simply benefited from the Brentford recruitment process, he does seem to have a type of player he likes (physical), and it would be interesting to see if it all ends up with Palace buying players of that type to suit the manager, rather than playing moneyball (as understandable as that approach is).